In short
The incidental question arises when the answer to a main conflict question governed by a foreign law depends on a second, subsidiary question that has its own conflict rule, such as whether a person is validly married when the main question is succession. The court must decide whether to answer the subsidiary question by the conflict rules of the lex causae or of the forum. The time factor deals with changes over time: in the connecting factor (for example a new domicile) or in the content of the governing law (for example retrospective foreign legislation). English courts, whose approach is received in Tanzania, decide both problems case by case, guided by Schwebel v Ungar, Lawrence v Lawrence and Starkowski v Attorney-General.
On this page 9 sections
- What is the incidental question?
- When does a true incidental question arise?
- How do courts answer the incidental question?
- Which cases illustrate the incidental question?
- What is the time factor (the conflict of laws in time)?
- How might these problems arise in Tanzania?
- Exam focus: what do examiners test on the incidental question and the time factor?
- Practice question: Fatma's claim as widow
- Key takeaways
What is the incidental question?
Many conflict cases contain a question inside a question. Suppose a man dies domiciled in Kenya leaving movables in Tanzania. Succession to the movables is governed by Kenyan law as the law of his domicile. Kenyan law gives a share to his “widow”. A woman claims to be the widow, but her marriage to him took place after an Indian divorce that Tanzanian law might not recognise. Is she his widow?
- The main question is succession, governed by Kenyan law.
- The incidental (subsidiary) question is the validity of her marriage, which has its own conflict rules.
If Kenyan conflict rules and Tanzanian conflict rules give different answers on the validity of the marriage, the result of the whole case depends on whose conflict rules the court uses for the incidental question.
When does a true incidental question arise?
Writers usually require three conditions:
- The main question is governed, under the forum’s conflict rules, by a foreign law.
- The subsidiary question has its own independent conflict rule (for example, validity of marriage or recognition of a divorce).
- The conflict rule of the lex causae and the conflict rule of the forum would give different answers to the subsidiary question.
If any condition is missing, there is no real incidental question and the court simply applies its normal rules.
How do courts answer the incidental question?
There are two approaches:
- Lex causae approach: answer the subsidiary question using the conflict rules of the law governing the main question. This promotes international harmony with the country whose law governs the main issue.
- Lex fori approach: answer it using the forum’s own conflict rules. This promotes internal consistency, so a person is not treated as married for one purpose and unmarried for another in the same country.
English law has not adopted a single rule; it decides each case on its own merits, and that flexible approach is what a Tanzanian court would apply under section 2(3) of JALA.
Which cases illustrate the incidental question?
Schwebel v Ungar (1964) 48 DLR (2d) 644 (Supreme Court of Canada)
A Jewish couple domiciled in Hungary were divorced by a religious get in Italy while emigrating to Israel. The divorce was not valid under the law of Ontario (the forum) but was recognised by Israeli law, where the wife then became domiciled. She later married in Ontario. The main question was her capacity to remarry, governed by Israeli law as the law of her domicile. The incidental question was the validity of her divorce. The court answered it by the lex causae (Israeli law), so she had capacity to remarry and her Ontario marriage was valid.
Key Statutes and Cases on The Incidental Question and the Time Factor
Statutes
- Judicature and Application of Laws Act, Cap. 358 R.E. 2019s. 2(3) reception of common law; ss. 9 and 11 internal choice of personal law
Cases
- Schwebel v Ungar (1964) 48 DLR (2d) 644Incidental question answered by the lex causae
- R v Brentwood Superintendent Registrar of Marriages, ex p Arias [1968] 2 QB 956Lex causae approach denied capacity to remarry
- Lawrence v Lawrence [1985] Fam 106Forum's recognition of a divorce upheld a second marriage
- Starkowski v Attorney-General [1954] AC 155Retrospective foreign validation of a marriage recognised
- Lynch v Provisional Government of Paraguay (1871) LR 2 P & D 268Retrospective confiscatory decree disregarded in succession
Test yourself
The Incidental Question and the Time Factor Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
