In short
Companies borrow, and lenders want security. A debenture is the document acknowledging a company’s debt, usually secured by a charge over its property. A fixed charge attaches to specific assets the company cannot deal with freely; a floating charge hovers over a changing class of assets, such as stock and book debts, until it crystallises. Most charges must be registered with BRELA within forty-two days of creation, or they are void against the liquidator, administrator and other creditors (ss.99 and 100 of the Companies Act, Cap. 212 R.E. 2023). If the company defaults, the chargeholder may appoint a receiver, who acts as the company’s agent and must pay preferential debts out of floating charge assets first (ss.98 and 409 to 427).
On this page 9 sections
- What is a debenture?
- What is the difference between a fixed and a floating charge?
- Which charges must be registered at BRELA?
- How and when must a charge be registered?
- How is a charge enforced through receivership?
- Who is paid first out of floating charge assets?
- Exam focus: what do examiners test on debentures and charges?
- Practice question: Pamba Mills Ltd and its lenders
- Key takeaways
What is a debenture?
The Act defines “debenture” broadly to include debenture stock, bonds and any other securities of a company, whether or not they create a charge on its assets (s.2). In everyday Tanzanian banking, “debenture” usually means the security document by which a company charges its assets, often all of them, to a bank to secure a loan or overdraft.
Debentures may be issued singly (to one bank) or in a series to many lenders who rank equally (pari passu), often through a trustee for the debenture holders. A company that issues debentures must keep a register of debenture holders, open to inspection (ss.91 and 92). Trustees for debenture holders cannot be exempted from liability for breach of trust where they fail to show proper care (s.93). Perpetual debentures, irredeemable or redeemable only on a contingency, are valid (s.94), and a contract to subscribe for debentures can be enforced by specific performance (s.97).
| Point | Shareholder | Debenture holder |
|---|---|---|
| Relationship | Member and owner | Creditor |
| Return | Dividend only if declared out of profits (s.183) | Interest payable whether or not there are profits |
| Voting | Usually votes at general meetings | No vote, but contractual rights and covenants |
| On winding up | Paid last, after all creditors | Paid as a creditor; if secured, from the charged assets |
What is the difference between a fixed and a floating charge?
Fixed charge
A fixed (specific) charge attaches immediately to identified property, such as a factory, land, a vehicle or a specific bank deposit. The company cannot sell or deal with the asset without the chargeholder’s consent. It gives the strongest priority.
Floating charge
In Re Yorkshire Woolcombers Association Ltd [1903] 2 Ch 284, Romer LJ identified three typical features of a floating charge:
- it is a charge on a class of assets, present and future;
- that class changes from time to time in the ordinary course of business; and
- until some step is taken by the chargeholder, the company may carry on business in the ordinary way with those assets.
The House of Lords affirmed this in Illingworth v Houldsworth [1904] AC 355, where Lord Macnaghten described a floating charge as ambulatory and shifting, remaining dormant until crystallised.
The label the parties use does not decide the matter; the court looks at the substance. In Agnew v Commissioner of Inland Revenue (Re Brumark) [2001] UKPC 28 and Re Spectrum Plus Ltd [2005] UKHL 41, charges over book debts described as “fixed” were held to be floating, because the company was free to collect the debts and use the proceeds in its business. A charge is fixed only if the chargeholder really controls the asset or its proceeds.
Crystallisation
A floating charge crystallises, and becomes fixed on the assets then in the class, when:
- the company goes into winding up;
- a receiver is appointed or the chargeholder takes possession;
- the company ceases to carry on business; or
- an event specified in the debenture occurs (automatic crystallisation clauses), as the instrument provides.
Priority between charges
- A fixed charge generally ranks ahead of an earlier floating charge over the same asset, because the floating charge allows the company to deal with its assets, including by granting fixed charges.
- Lenders respond with negative pledge clauses forbidding the company to create later charges with priority. A later chargeholder who has notice of the clause is bound by it.
- Between two fixed charges, the earlier in time usually prevails, subject to the registration rules.
Which charges must be registered at BRELA?
Under s.100(1), the registration requirement applies to:
- a charge securing an issue of debentures;
- a charge on uncalled share capital;
- a charge created by an instrument that would need registration as a bill of sale if made by an individual;
- a charge on land, wherever situated, or any interest in land;
- a charge on book debts;
- a floating charge on the company’s undertaking or property;
- a charge on calls made but not paid;
- a charge on a ship, aircraft or any share in a ship; and
- a charge on goodwill or on intellectual property (patents, trademarks, registered designs, copyright, design rights and licences).
Key Statutes and Cases on Debentures, Charges and Receivership
Statutes
- Companies Act, Cap. 212 R.E. 2023ss.2, 91 to 112, 370, 375, 409 to 427
Cases
- Re Yorkshire Woolcombers Association Ltd [1903] 2 Ch 284Characteristics of a floating charge
- Illingworth v Houldsworth [1904] AC 355Nature of a floating charge
- Agnew v Commissioner of Inland Revenue (Re Brumark) [2001] UKPC 28Substance decides fixed or floating
- Re Spectrum Plus Ltd [2005] UKHL 41Book debts charge was floating
Test yourself
Debentures, Charges and Receivership in Tanzania Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
