Company Law notes · Topic 17 of 20

Shareholder Remedies in Tanzania

Minority protection in Tanzanian company law: the rule in Foss v Harbottle and its exceptions, the statutory derivative action under s.237 (Mohamed Abdillah Nur v Hamad Masauni), unfair prejudice petitions under s.236, reflective loss, investigations and just and equitable winding up.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 16 min read

In short

In a company, the majority rules. When a wrong is done to the company, the company itself is the proper plaintiff, and if the majority can lawfully ratify an irregularity, the court will not interfere at a minority’s request (Foss v Harbottle). But minority shareholders are not left without protection. The Companies Act, Cap. 212 R.E. 2023 gives them a statutory derivative action, brought with the court’s leave in the company’s name (s.237); an unfair prejudice petition with wide remedies, including an order that their shares be bought (s.236); the right to enforce their personal rights under the articles; investigation of the company’s affairs (s.220); and, as a last resort, a petition to wind up the company on the just and equitable ground (s.282(1)(e)).

On this page 9 sections
  1. What is the rule in Foss v Harbottle?
  2. What were the common law exceptions?
  3. How does the statutory derivative action work (s.237)?
  4. When can a member petition for unfair prejudice (s.236)?
  5. What other remedies do shareholders have?
  6. How do you choose the right shareholder remedy?
  7. Exam focus: what do examiners test on shareholder remedies?
  8. Practice question: Mwambao Fisheries Ltd
  9. Key takeaways

What is the rule in Foss v Harbottle?

In Foss v Harbottle (1843) 2 Hare 461, two shareholders sued the directors of a company, alleging they had sold their own land to the company at inflated prices. The court dismissed the claim. Two principles came from the case:

  1. The proper plaintiff rule. A wrong done to the company is a wrong to the company, a separate legal person, so only the company can sue for it (see Corporate Personality and Limited Liability).
  2. The majority rule (internal management) principle. If the irregularity is one the majority could lawfully ratify, the court will not interfere at the suit of a minority, because the majority could simply approve it at a meeting.

The rule avoids a flood of suits by individual shareholders, prevents pointless litigation over matters the majority could cure, and respects majority decision-making. Its weakness is obvious: if the wrongdoers control the board and the majority, the company will never sue them.

What were the common law exceptions?

In Edwards v Halliwell [1950] 2 All ER 1064, Jenkins LJ summarised the cases where a minority member could sue despite the rule:

  • Illegal or ultra vires acts, which no majority can ratify.
  • Acts requiring a special majority but passed by a simple majority. In Edwards v Halliwell itself, a trade union increased members’ contributions without the two-thirds ballot its rules required.
  • Invasion of personal rights of the member, such as the right to vote (Pender v Lushington (1877) 6 Ch D 70).
  • Fraud on the minority by wrongdoers in control: where those in control appropriate the company’s property for themselves, as in Cook v Deeks [1916] 1 AC 554, where directors diverted a company contract to themselves and used their votes to declare that the company had no interest in it. That was a fraud on the minority that the majority could not ratify.

The fraud on the minority exception was hard to use. In Prudential Assurance Co Ltd v Newman Industries Ltd (No 2) [1982] Ch 204, the Court of Appeal held that the claimant must first establish, as a preliminary issue, that the company is entitled to the relief and that the action falls within the exception, including wrongdoer control. This made common law derivative actions slow and expensive, which led to statutory reform.

How does the statutory derivative action work (s.237)?

Section 237 replaces the uncertain common law route with a clear procedure. Before the 2023 revision it was s.234.

  1. Leave of the court (s.237(1)). An applicant may apply to the court for leave to bring an action in the name and on behalf of the company or any of its subsidiaries, or to intervene in an action to which the company is a party, for the purpose of prosecuting, defending or discontinuing it.
  2. Three conditions (s.237(2)). The court must be satisfied that:
    • (a) the applicant has given reasonable notice to the directors of the intention to apply, if the directors do not bring, diligently prosecute or defend, or discontinue the action;
    • (b) the applicant is acting in good faith; and
    • (c) it appears to be in the interests of the company that the action be brought, prosecuted, defended or discontinued.
  3. Court’s powers (s.237(3)). The court may authorise the applicant, the Registrar or another person to control the action, give directions, order that any amount recovered be paid directly to former and present shareholders or debenture holders instead of to the company, and require the company to pay the applicant’s reasonable legal fees.

The Tanzanian authority: Mohamed Abdillah Nur v Hamad Masauni

In Mohamed Abdillah Nur and Others v Hamad Masauni and Others, Civil Appeal No. 630 of 2023, [2024] TZCA 129, the three founding shareholders of a company had entered into a joint venture and share purchase agreement under which an investor was to pay USD 4,000,000 for 65% of the shares. The founders, now minority shareholders, brought a derivative action under the provision (then s.234) after obtaining the High Court’s leave, alleging the money was never paid. The High Court declared the agreements void, ordered the return of the 65% shares and awarded damages. On appeal, the appellants argued that the statutory notice had not been properly given to the directors. The Court of Appeal held that the notice requirement is decided at the leave stage: the High Court had already found at that stage that notice was served, and the appellants should have challenged that finding then or by appealing that decision, not in the appeal against the final judgment. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Key Statutes and Cases on Shareholder Remedies

Statutes

  • Companies Act, Cap. 212 R.E. 2023ss.19, 37(2), 38(4), 75, 124, 137, 140, 220, 224 to 227, 236, 237, 282(1)(e)

Cases

  • Mohamed Abdillah Nur and Others v Hamad Masauni and Others, Civil Appeal No. 630 of 2023, [2024] TZCA 129Derivative action; notice decided at the leave stage
  • Foss v Harbottle (1843) 2 Hare 461Proper plaintiff and majority rule
  • Edwards v Halliwell [1950] 2 All ER 1064Exceptions to the rule
  • Cook v Deeks [1916] 1 AC 554Fraud on the minority
  • Prudential Assurance Co Ltd v Newman Industries Ltd (No 2) [1982] Ch 204Preliminary issue in derivative actions
  • O'Neill v Phillips [1999] 1 WLR 1092Meaning of unfair prejudice
  • Re Bird Precision Bellows Ltd [1986] Ch 658Buy-out valuation
  • Johnson v Gore Wood & Co [2002] 2 AC 1Reflective loss
  • Ebrahimi v Westbourne Galleries Ltd [1973] AC 360Just and equitable winding up

Test yourself

Shareholder Remedies in Tanzania Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free

Take the quiz

Get the Full Company Law Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Keep reading this topicFrom TSh 5,000 a weekJoin Now