Civil Procedure notes · Topic 20 of 20

Alternative Dispute Resolution and Court-Annexed Mediation

How modern Tanzanian civil procedure requires parties to attempt mediation before trial, plus arbitration under Cap. 15 R.E. 2023 and reconciliation in suits.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 11 min read

The old picture was simple: a civil dispute went to trial, the trial decided who was right, and the loser paid. The reality is that trials are slow, expensive, and often leave both sides worse off than if they had settled.

The CPC now treats mediation as a mandatory step in most civil suits before they can go to trial. Beyond mediation, the law provides for arbitration as a binding alternative to court litigation. And reconciliation remains an option in suits where the parties may benefit from a negotiated settlement.

Together, these mechanisms are called alternative dispute resolution — ADR. The word “alternative” is misleading. In Tanzania today, ADR is no longer optional. Court-annexed mediation is part of the civil process, not a side option.

This is the final topic of the course, and it brings together everything we have learned. The trial procedure is the destination; ADR is the path the law wants you to try first.

What ADR Is

Alternative dispute resolution (ADR) is any method of resolving disputes other than contested trial. The principal forms are:

Negotiation — direct talks between the parties, often through their advocates.

Mediation — a process in which a neutral third person (the mediator) helps the parties reach their own voluntary settlement.

Arbitration — a process in which the parties refer their dispute to one or more independent arbitrators for a binding decision, called an award.

Conciliation — similar to mediation, but the conciliator may take a more active role in proposing settlement terms.

Court-annexed mediation is mediation conducted within the court process — the court refers the parties to a mediator at a defined stage of the suit.

The Policy Behind the Reform

The Tanzanian reforms reflect a deliberate policy choice. Several reasons drove the change:

Court congestion. Tanzanian courts have always had heavy caseloads. Forcing every dispute through full trial overwhelms the system.

Cost. Litigation is expensive — for the parties and for the state. Settlement reduces costs.

Speed. Trials take months or years. Mediation can settle a case in a single sitting.

Quality of outcome. A negotiated settlement reflects what the parties themselves accept; a court judgment is imposed from outside. Settlements are more likely to be honoured.

Relationship preservation. In commercial and family disputes, the parties often have an ongoing relationship. Trial destroys it; mediation may preserve it.

The reforms recognise that settlement is generally better than trial, when settlement is possible.

Court-Annexed Mediation — How It Works in the CPC

The legal framework

The CPC has dedicated Orders that introduce the mediation framework — typically referred to as Order VIIIA (the first pre-trial settlement and scheduling conference), Order VIIIB (mediation), and Order VIIIC (the final pre-trial settlement and scheduling conference). The numbering may vary in your faculty’s print copy, so verify against the R.E. 2023 edition.

The system, as it operates, has the following structure.

The scheduling conference

Soon after pleadings are closed, the court holds a scheduling conference with the parties. The conference:

Classifies the case into a speed track — fast, normal, or extended — with target timelines for disposal.

Identifies the issues genuinely in dispute.

Refers the parties to mediation before trial.

Court-annexed mediation

The parties are referred to a mediator — typically a judge, magistrate, or trained accredited mediator. The mediation is mandatory. The parties must attend in good faith.

The mediator’s role is to help the parties reach their own agreement. The mediator does not decide the case. He listens to both sides, identifies the strengths and weaknesses of each, and helps the parties find common ground.

The mediation procedure — stage by stage

Tanzanian court-annexed mediation follows a recognisable sequence:

Stage 1 — The plaintiff narrates. The plaintiff (or his advocate) sets out his claims against the defendant and explains the remedies he is seeking.

Stage 2 — The defendant narrates. The defendant sets out his side of the case and tells what he seeks by way of remedies.

Stage 3 — The mediator assesses. The mediator listens to both, takes brief notes, and forms a working view of the case.

Stage 4 — Private sessions with one side. The mediator may ask the plaintiff and his lawyer to leave the room, and then discuss the case privately with the defendant — outlining the weaknesses and strengths of his position, and suggesting what compromises he might consider.

Key Statutes and Cases on Alternative Dispute Resolution and Court-Annexed Mediation

Statutes

  • Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2023s. 71 conciliation, negotiation and mediation; Order VIII rr. 24 to 34 mediation

Test yourself

Alternative Dispute Resolution and Court-Annexed Mediation Practice Quiz Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free

Take the quiz

Get the Full Civil Procedure Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Keep reading this topicFrom TSh 5,000 a weekJoin Now