On this page 13 sections
- Introduction to Dispute Settlement Methods
- Why Compare Different Dispute Settlement Systems?
- Dispute Settlement in Communal Societies (Customary Law)
- Procedures for Dispute Settlement Under Customary Law
- Outcomes of Traditional Dispute Settlement
- Dispute Settlement in Market Economy Societies (Common Law System)
- Criminal Procedure in Tanzania
- The Civil Law (Inquisitorial) System
- Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)
- Mediation
- Conciliation
- Arbitration
- Exam Tips and Key Takeaways
Introduction to Dispute Settlement Methods
Every society develops its own ways of resolving conflicts between individuals or groups. These methods are shaped by the social structure, economic system, cultural values, and historical development of that society.
Disputes may arise from issues such as:
-
Land ownership or use
-
Contracts and business transactions
-
Family disagreements
-
Criminal conduct
-
Employment relations
Because societies differ, the methods used to resolve disputes also differ.
Legal scholars such as Arthur von Mehren have argued that dispute resolution procedures are deeply influenced by the socio-economic organization of a society. A system designed for one social environment may not work effectively in another without adaptation.
In legal studies, four major dispute settlement systems are commonly examined:
-
Common Law Adversarial System
-
Customary Law (Traditional African Methods)
-
Civil Law Inquisitorial System
-
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)
Understanding these systems helps law students appreciate how different legal traditions approach justice and conflict resolution.
Why Compare Different Dispute Settlement Systems?
Comparing systems of dispute settlement helps students understand:
-
How law interacts with society and culture
-
Why legal procedures differ across countries
-
The advantages and limitations of each system
For example:
-
Traditional African systems focus on restoring social harmony.
-
Common Law systems focus on enforcing individual legal rights.
-
Civil Law systems emphasize judicial investigation.
-
ADR methods emphasize negotiation and flexibility.
Many African legal systems, including Tanzania’s, reflect a combination of these traditions due to colonial history and modern legal reforms.
Dispute Settlement in Communal Societies (Customary Law)
Nature of Customary Law in African Societies
Before colonization, African societies already had well-established systems for resolving disputes. These systems were not based on formal courts or written laws but were guided by:
-
Community customs
-
Moral values
-
Social harmony
-
Authority of elders or clan leaders
The objective was restoration of peace within the community, rather than punishment or strict legal victory.
In Tanzania, customary law continues to influence dispute resolution, particularly in matters related to:
-
Family law
-
Land disputes
-
Local community conflicts
The recognition of customary law in Tanzania can be seen in legislation such as:
-
Local Customary Law (Declaration) Order, 1963
-
Judicature and Application of Laws Act, Cap 358 R.E 2023
Basic Principles of Land Rights in Communal Societies
In traditional communal societies, land is treated differently from modern capitalist systems.
The key principles include:
Land Has Use Value Rather Than Exchange Value
Land is valued for its ability to support livelihood, such as:
-
Farming
-
Grazing
-
Settlement
It is not treated as a commodity for buying and selling.
Land Is Held Communally
Land is normally held by:
-
A clan
-
A lineage group
-
The community
Individuals usually possess rights of use, not absolute ownership.
Focus on Possession and Use
In disputes involving land, the main question is:
Who has the right to use or occupy the land, not who owns it absolutely.
Rights Are Relative, Not Absolute
In Western property law, ownership is a right in rem — a right enforceable against the entire world.
In communal societies:
-
Land rights are relative
-
Rights depend on the relationship between the parties involved.
No Clear Distinction Between Property and Tort
In customary law:
-
A person who is dispossessed of land may bring a claim against the wrongdoer.
-
The action protects possession rather than abstract ownership.
Important Tanzanian Cases on Customary Land Rights
Issack s/o Nguvumali v Petro s/o Bikulako (1972) HCD n.139
The High Court recognized that customary land rights are based on use and occupation, rather than formal title.
The case illustrates how courts consider customary principles when resolving land disputes.
Swalehe v Slim (1972) HCD n.140
The court acknowledged that under customary law, long possession and community recognition can establish rights to land.
Kapasyu v Mwandilemo [1968] HCD n.88
This case confirmed that customary land rights arise through:
-
Occupation
-
Community acceptance
-
Traditional authority
Kadume’s Case
This case demonstrates how disputes were sometimes handled within lineage groups before being taken to wider community forums.
Procedures for Dispute Settlement Under Customary Law
Customary dispute settlement procedures differ significantly from formal court litigation.
They are typically:
-
Informal
-
Community-based
-
Focused on reconciliation
The Indaba (Village Elders’ Hearing)
One common method is the Indaba, a gathering of elders and community members.
Key features include:
-
Public discussion of the dispute
-
Participation of elders and community members
-
Examination of witnesses
-
Collective deliberation
The elders apply community norms and customary rules to reach a decision.
The aim is to restore harmony rather than assign blame.
This approach was recognized in Swalehe v Salim (1972) HCD n.140.
Lineage Counsellor and Internal Moot
Sometimes disputes are resolved within the family or clan before becoming public.
The lineage counsellor:
-
Calls a meeting of family members
-
Allows both sides to explain their positions
-
Encourages reconciliation
This internal process is sometimes called a lineage moot.
Public Denunciation (Drumming the Scandal)
Among the Tiv people of Nigeria, an aggrieved party could publicly shame a wrongdoer by drumming out the scandal.
The act involved:
-
Public performance
-
Exposure of wrongdoing
-
Social pressure for correction
Anthropologist Paul Bohannan described this practice in:
Paul Bohannan, Justice and Judgment Among the Tiv (1957).
Although not practiced in Tanzania, it illustrates how communities enforce social norms through public accountability.
Trial by Ordeal
Some traditional societies used trial by ordeal, where the outcome of a physical test was believed to reflect divine judgment.
For example, a person might:
-
Hold a hot object
-
Drink a special potion
-
Undergo another physical test
If they survived or passed the test, they were considered innocent.
Case Example
Palamba s/o Fundikira v R (1947) 14 EACA 96
The case dealt with the legal implications of a traditional trial by ordeal in Tanganyika.
The court examined how such practices interact with modern criminal law.
Outcomes of Traditional Dispute Settlement
Traditional systems rarely produce a strict winner and loser.
Instead, possible outcomes include:
Reconciliation
The parties restore their relationship.
Example:
Two neighbours fighting over farmland may be reconciled through:
-
Apology
-
Symbolic compensation
-
Community mediation.
Compromise
Both parties concede something.
This promotes social peace.
Compensation
The wrongdoer compensates the injured party through:
-
Livestock
-
Produce
-
Labour
-
Money (in modern contexts)
Philosophy of Traditional Justice
Traditional dispute settlement reflects the principle:
“Win a little, lose a little.”
The aim is social harmony, not legal victory.
This contrasts with the Common Law system, which typically produces a clear winner and loser.
Dispute Settlement in Market Economy Societies (Common Law System)
Nature of the Common Law Adversarial System
The Common Law system developed in England and spread to many countries through colonization.
Tanzania inherited this system through British colonial administration.
The system is based on the adversarial model, meaning:
-
Two opposing parties present their cases
-
A neutral judge decides the dispute.
Basic Principles of Land Rights in Market Economies
In modern market economies:
Land Is a Commodity
Land has exchange value and can be:
-
Bought
-
Sold
-
Leased
-
Mortgaged.
Ownership Is Absolute
Property rights can be enforced against the whole world.
Transfer of Title
A purchaser must ensure they acquire good title.
Land transactions are regulated under laws such as:
-
Land Act, Cap 113 R.E 2023
-
Village Land Act, Cap 114 R.E 2023
-
Land Registration Act, Cap 334 R.E 2023
These laws provide systems for:
-
Land registration
-
Transfer of title
-
Protection of ownership rights.
Overview of Civil Litigation in Tanzania
Civil litigation in Tanzania is governed primarily by:
The Civil Procedure Code, Cap 33 R.E 2023.
Civil proceedings usually follow several stages.
Pleadings and Service of Process
The plaintiff begins the case by filing a plaint.
Relevant provisions include:
-
Section 22 Civil Procedure Code
-
Order VII of the Civil Procedure Code
The plaint must contain:
-
Facts constituting the cause of action
-
The relief sought
-
Details of the parties.
The defendant must then be served with court documents.
Defence
The defendant may file a Written Statement of Defence.
Possible responses include:
-
Traverse – denying the plaintiff’s allegations
-
Confession and avoidance – admitting facts but raising a legal defense
-
Preliminary objection – challenging legal validity of the case.
Jurisdiction
Before filing a case, the plaintiff must consider jurisdiction.
Jurisdiction may depend on:
-
Subject matter
-
Territorial location
-
Pecuniary value of the claim
Jurisdiction of courts in Tanzania is governed by:
-
Magistrates’ Courts Act, Cap 11 R.E 2023
-
Judicature and Application of Laws Act, Cap 358 R.E 2023
Trial
During trial:
-
Witnesses testify
-
Evidence is presented
-
Lawyers make arguments
-
Witnesses are cross-examined.
The judge then makes a decision (judgment).
Execution of Judgment
If a party wins the case, the court may enforce the decision through execution of the decree.
Execution may involve:
-
Attachment of property
-
Sale of assets
-
Payment orders.
Appeals
An aggrieved party may appeal to a higher court.
Typical hierarchy:
-
Primary Court
-
District Court / Resident Magistrate Court
-
High Court of Tanzania
-
Court of Appeal of Tanzania
Criminal Procedure in Tanzania
Criminal cases are governed by:
Criminal Procedure Act, Cap 20 R.E 2023
Parties in Criminal Cases
-
The State (Prosecution) represented by the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP)
-
The Accused Person
Commencement of Criminal Proceedings
A criminal case begins with:
-
A charge sheet, or
-
An information filed in court.
The accused is brought to court through:
-
Summons, or
-
Arrest warrant.
Public and Private Prosecution
Most prosecutions are conducted by the DPP or state prosecutors.
Private prosecutions may occur but are subject to legal restrictions.
Ward Tribunals
At the community level, minor disputes may be handled by Ward Tribunals established under:
Ward Tribunals Act, Cap 206 R.E 2023
These tribunals aim to:
-
Promote reconciliation
-
Reduce court congestion
-
Resolve minor disputes locally.
The Civil Law (Inquisitorial) System
Historical Development
The Civil Law system originates from:
-
Roman law
-
Corpus Juris Civilis of Emperor Justinian (6th century AD)
Later developments include:
-
Napoleonic Civil Code (1804)
-
German Civil Code (BGB, 1900)
Many European and Latin American countries follow this system.
The Inquisitorial Model
In the inquisitorial system, the judge actively investigates the case.
The judge may:
-
Question witnesses
-
Request documents
-
Direct the investigation.
The judge is therefore not merely a passive referee.
Key Differences Between Adversarial and Inquisitorial Systems
Role of the Judge
Adversarial system:
-
Judge acts as a neutral arbiter.
Inquisitorial system:
-
Judge acts as an active investigator.
Role of Lawyers
Adversarial system:
-
Lawyers control the case.
Inquisitorial system:
-
Lawyers assist the judge.
Method of Proceedings
Adversarial systems emphasize:
-
Oral arguments
-
Cross-examination
Civil Law systems emphasize:
-
Written documentation.
Role of Precedent
Common Law systems rely heavily on judicial precedent.
Civil Law systems rely primarily on legal codes.
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)
Meaning of ADR
Alternative Dispute Resolution refers to methods of resolving disputes outside formal court litigation.
ADR has become increasingly important because courts often face:
-
Backlog of cases
-
High litigation costs
-
Long delays.
ADR mechanisms include:
-
Mediation
-
Conciliation
-
Arbitration
Mediation
Mediation is a process where a neutral third party (mediator) helps disputing parties reach a voluntary agreement.
Key characteristics:
-
Voluntary
-
Confidential
-
Non-binding unless parties agree
-
Preserves relationships.
In Tanzania, court-annexed mediation is provided under the Civil Procedure Code, Cap 33 R.E 2023.
Conciliation
Conciliation is similar to mediation but the conciliator may suggest solutions.
In Tanzania, conciliation is commonly used in labour disputes.
Relevant legislation includes:
Labour Institutions Act, Cap 300 R.E 2023
Employment disputes must first go through conciliation before proceeding to:
-
Arbitration
-
Labour Division of the High Court.
Arbitration
Arbitration is a private dispute resolution process where parties submit their dispute to an arbitrator, who makes a binding decision called an award.
Key features:
-
Based on agreement of parties
-
Confidential proceedings
-
Binding decision
-
Enforceable award.
In Tanzania, arbitration is governed by:
Arbitration Act, Cap 15 R.E 2023
Arbitration is widely used in:
-
Commercial disputes
-
Construction contracts
-
International business agreements.
Exam Tips and Key Takeaways
Students should remember the following key distinctions:
Traditional African systems
-
Focus on reconciliation
-
Community participation
-
Flexible procedures
Common Law system
-
Adversarial litigation
-
Formal procedures
-
Clear winner and loser
Civil Law system
-
Judge-led investigation
-
Code-based legal system
ADR mechanisms
-
Faster and cheaper
-
Confidential
-
Promote settlement outside courts
Understanding these systems helps law students appreciate how different societies design institutions for justice and dispute resolution.
Test yourself
Dispute Settlement Methods in Law Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback
