Constitutional Law notes · Topic 9 of 12

The Bill of Rights: Nature, Scope and Limitations

Understanding Part III of the Constitution — enforceable rights, Directive Principles, the limitation clause, and derogation during emergencies.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 25 min read
On this page 29 sections
  1. Introduction
  2. Structure of Part III — Basic Rights and Duties
  3. Part II — Fundamental Objectives and Directive Principles of State Policy (Articles 7–11)
  4. Part III — Basic Rights and Duties (Articles 12–28A)
  5. Key Individual Rights Under Part III — Overview
  6. Article 12 — The Equality of Human Beings
  7. Article 13 — Equality Before the Law and Non-Discrimination
  8. Article 14 — The Right to Life
  9. Article 15 — Right to Personal Freedom
  10. Article 16 — Right to Privacy
  11. Practical Examples
  12. Article 18 — Freedom of Expression
  13. Article 19 — Freedom of Conscience and Religion
  14. Article 20 — Freedom of Association
  15. Article 21 — Right to Participate in Public Affairs
  16. The Mtikila Constitutional Saga — Independent Candidates
  17. Quick Summary
  18. Article 22 — Right to Work
  19. Article 23 — Right to Just Remuneration
  20. Article 24 — Right to Own Property
  21. Land Law and the Constitution
  22. Part II — Directive Principles (Non-Justiciable Rights)
  23. Articles 25–28A — Duties of Citizens
  24. Important Case Law
  25. Practical Scenario
  26. Quick Summary
  27. The Limitation Clause — Article 30(2)
  28. Derogation During a State of Emergency (Articles 31–32)
  29. Horizontal Application of Rights (Third Party Effect)

Introduction

The Bill of Rights in Part III of the Constitution of Tanzania is the cornerstone of human rights protection in the country. It guarantees the basic rights and freedoms of every person in Tanzania — regardless of race, sex, religion, political opinion, or any other status. These rights are not gifts from the government; they are inherent entitlements that the Constitution recognises and protects.

As a law student, you will use the Bill of Rights constantly — in criminal defence (invoking the right to a fair trial), family law (equality between spouses), land law (property rights), employment (freedom of association), and civil matters. Mastering Part III is not optional.

Structure of Part III — Basic Rights and Duties

The Two-Part System

Tanzania’s Constitution divides fundamental law into two parts that are critically different:

Part II — Fundamental Objectives and Directive Principles of State Policy (Articles 7–11)

Part II contains statements of national goals and aspirations — the right to development, the right to work, the duty to protect national resources, the goal of building a socialist state, etc. These provisions are NOT enforceable in court. You cannot sue the government for failing to achieve “socialist development.” They guide government policy but are not justiciable.

Article 9 (duty to control the national economy) and Article 11 (right to social welfare) are examples of non-justiciable provisions. Courts will not hear petitions based solely on these articles.

Part III — Basic Rights and Duties (Articles 12–28A)

Part III contains the genuinely enforceable rights — rights that can be enforced in the High Court through constitutional petitions. These include equality, personal liberty, freedom of expression, freedom of religion, property rights, and others discussed in detail in Weeks 10 and 11.

Article 30(3): “Any person who alleges that any provision of this Part [Part III], which guarantees the basic rights, freedoms and duties, has been, is being or is likely to be contravened in relation to him, may institute proceedings for redress in the High Court.” This is the enforcement provision — only Part III rights can be enforced this way, not Part II.

Key Individual Rights Under Part III — Overview

  • Article 12 — Equality of human beings: every person is born free and equal.

  • Article 13 — Equality before the law: equal treatment; non-discrimination.

  • Article 14 — Right to life and bodily integrity.

  • Article 15 — Right to personal freedom (protection against unlawful arrest/detention).

  • Article 16 — Right to privacy.

  • Article 17 — Freedom of movement.

  • Article 18 — Freedom of expression.

  • Article 19 — Freedom of conscience and religion.

  • Article 20 — Freedom of association.

  • Article 21 — Right to participate in public affairs.

  • Article 22 — Right to work.

  • Article 23 — Right to just remuneration.

  • Article 24 — Right to own property.

  • Articles 25–28A — Duties of citizens.

Article 12 — The Equality of Human Beings

Article 12(1): “All human beings are born free, and are equal.” This is a foundational dignity clause. It establishes that every person has inherent dignity and worth. It is the philosophical foundation for all other rights.

Article 12(2): “Every person has a right to be recognised and treated as a human being before the law.” This means that the legal system must recognise every person — regardless of wealth, social status, or ethnicity — as having full legal personality and equality.

Article 13 — Equality Before the Law and Non-Discrimination

Article 13(1) — Equal Treatment

Article 13(1): “All persons are equal before the law and are entitled, without any discrimination, to protection and equality before the law.”

This has two components: (a) equal protection — the law must apply equally to everyone; and (b) equal treatment — government and its institutions must treat all persons equally.

Article 13(4) — Non-Discrimination

Article 13(4): “No person shall be discriminated against by any person acting under any law or in the discharge of the functions or business of any government institution.” The prohibited grounds of discrimination include: sex, race, nationality, tribe, place of origin, political opinion, religion, and any condition in which a person is in.

This means both public authorities AND private persons acting under a law cannot discriminate on these grounds.

Article 13(6) — Fair Trial Rights

Article 13(6) guarantees several procedural rights in the criminal justice process:

  • Presumption of innocence: every accused is presumed innocent until proved guilty.

  • Right to be informed of the charge in a language they understand.

  • Right to adequate time to prepare a defence.

  • Right to be tried in one’s presence and to defend oneself.

  • Right not to be compelled to testify against oneself.

  • Protection against double jeopardy: not to be tried again for an offence for which one has been acquitted or convicted.

  • Protection against retrospective criminal punishment (nulla poena sine lege).

Article 14 — The Right to Life

Article 14: “Every person has the right to live and to the protection of his life by the society in accordance with the law.”

This right has several dimensions:

Negative Obligation

The state must not arbitrarily take a person’s life. Any killing by the state (through the police, military, etc.) must be legally justified — e.g., in lawful self-defence or in the execution of a lawful sentence after a fair trial.

Positive Obligation

The words “protection of his life by the society” suggest a positive obligation — the state must take reasonable measures to protect lives. This has implications for: (a) medical care — the state has some duty to ensure basic healthcare; (b) environmental protection — the state must protect people from life-threatening environmental hazards; (c) protection from violent crime.

Capital Punishment and the Right to Life

The debate on capital punishment in Tanzania is one of the most significant intersections of the right to life with the criminal justice system. Tanzania retains capital punishment for murder (Penal Code Cap. 16, Section 196) and treason. The debate is whether capital punishment violates Article 14.

Mbushuu Case (discussed below): The High Court held in 1994 that the mandatory death penalty was unconstitutional. The Court of Appeal reversed this on the specific issue of mandatory sentencing, but the underlying tension between capital punishment and Article 14 has not been definitively resolved.

Article 15 — Right to Personal Freedom

Article 15(1): “Every person has the right to personal freedom, that is to say, the right not to be subjected to arrest, restraint, detention, imprisonment or exile except as may be authorised by law.”

Article 15(2): A person who is arrested: (a) must be informed of the reason for their arrest at the time of arrest; (b) must be charged and brought before a court within 48 hours of arrest; (c) if not charged, must be released.

Habeas Corpus

The writ of habeas corpus (Latin: “you shall have the body”) is the primary remedy for unlawful detention. A person detained can apply to the High Court (or sometimes a Resident Magistrate Court) for an order requiring the detaining authority to produce the detained person and justify the detention. If the detention is unlawful, the court orders immediate release. This right is available at any time — including nights, weekends, and holidays.

Article 16 — Right to Privacy

Article 16(1): “Every person is entitled to respect and protection of his person, the privacy of his own person, his family and of his matrimonial life, and respect and protection of his residence and private communications.”

This right protects individuals from:

  • Unlawful searches of their home or person.

  • Surveillance of their private communications without legal authority.

  • Intrusion into family life without justification.

  • Disclosure of private personal information.

In the digital age, Article 16 is becoming increasingly important — government surveillance of online communications, interception of telephone calls, and access to private data must all be justified by law and proportionate.

Important Case Law

CASE 1: Chumchua s/o Marwa v. Officer in Charge of Musoma Prison, Misc. Criminal Cause No. 2/1988 (High Court, Mwanza)

Court: High Court of Tanzania, Mwanza

Year: 1988

Facts: Chumchua was held in prison well beyond the expiry of his sentence. No fresh charges had been brought against him. He applied for habeas corpus.

Legal Issue: Does continued detention after a sentence has expired violate Article 15?

Decision: Mwalusanya J held that Chumchua’s continued detention was wholly illegal and ordered his immediate release. He held that Article 15 creates an absolute obligation — once the legal basis for detention has ended, continued detention is a violation of the right to personal freedom that the court must remedy immediately.

Principle: The right to personal freedom under Article 15 is not merely declaratory. It is an immediately enforceable right, and courts must act without delay when it is violated. This case established habeas corpus as a practical and effective constitutional remedy in Tanzania.

CASE 2: Bernardo Ephraim v. Holaria Pastory & Gervazi Kaizilege [1990] LRC (Const) 757 (High Court, Arusha)

Court: High Court of Tanzania, Arusha

Year: 1990

Judge: Mwalusanya J

Facts: A woman (Holaria Pastory) was given land by her father. After his death, she sold the land to a third party. Male relatives challenged the sale, arguing that Haya customary law prohibited women from selling clan land. The Primary Court and District Court applied customary law to invalidate the sale. Pastory appealed to the High Court.

Legal Issue: Can customary law that prohibits women from selling clan land (on the basis of sex) be applied by the courts in light of Article 13(4)’s prohibition of discrimination on grounds of sex?

Decision: Mwalusanya J held: (1) Article 13(4) prohibits discrimination on grounds of sex. (2) The Haya customary rule prohibiting women from selling clan land is discriminatory on grounds of sex. (3) Under Article 64(5), any law (including customary law) inconsistent with the Constitution is void to the extent of the inconsistency. (4) The customary rule was declared void. (5) The sale was valid.

Principle: (1) The constitutional right to equality overrides conflicting customary law. (2) Courts cannot apply customary rules that discriminate on prohibited grounds. (3) This case is a landmark for gender equality in Tanzanian law. It is heavily tested in exams.

CASE 3: Republic v. Mbushuu alias Dominic Mnyaroje & Another [1994] TLR 146 (High Court)

Court: High Court of Tanzania

Year: 1994

Facts: Two accused persons were convicted of murder and sentenced to death. They challenged the mandatory death penalty as unconstitutional under Article 14 (right to life) and Article 13(6)(e) (protection against cruel, inhuman, or degrading punishment).

Decision at High Court: Mwalusanya J held that: (1) The mandatory death penalty constitutes cruel and degrading punishment, violating Article 13(6)(e). (2) Capital punishment itself violates the right to life under Article 14 when applied as a mandatory sentence. He declared the mandatory death penalty unconstitutional.

On Appeal (Court of Appeal [1995] TLR 97): The Court of Appeal reversed in part, holding that capital punishment is not per se unconstitutional in Tanzania — the Constitution itself refers to “protection of his life… in accordance with the law,” implying that lawful execution following a fair trial is constitutionally permissible. However, the mandatory nature (no judicial discretion in sentencing) raised concerns.

Principle: Capital punishment, when imposed after a fair trial and with judicial discretion, is not per se unconstitutional in Tanzania. However, mandatory death penalties that remove judicial discretion in sentencing remain constitutionally questionable. This tension has not been fully resolved.

Practical Examples

Example 1: Unlawful Arrest

Police arrest Fatuma without a warrant, without informing her of the reason for arrest, and detain her for 72 hours without charge. She is held in a police cell and denied access to family or a lawyer. Her husband applies for habeas corpus. The court would: (1) order her immediate production and release; (2) find violations of Articles 15(1) and 15(2)(a) and (b) (right to be informed, 48-hour rule); and (3) potentially award compensation under the Basic Rights and Duties Enforcement Act (Cap. 3).

Example 2: Sex Discrimination in Employment

A private company’s policy states: “All management positions are reserved for male employees.” A female employee is denied promotion solely because of her sex. While the directly binding effect of Article 13(4) against private employers is debated, the Employment and Labour Relations Act (Cap. 366, Section 7) prohibits discrimination in employment on grounds of sex, giving indirect constitutional effect to Article 13(4) in the private employment context.

Article 17 — Freedom of Movement

Article 17(1): “Every citizen of Tanzania has the right to freedom of movement.” This includes: (a) the right to live anywhere in Tanzania; (b) the right to leave and return to Tanzania; (c) freedom from forced displacement within Tanzania.

Article 17(2) permits limitations on movement for: court orders, immigration control, public health, public order, protection of minors, and execution of criminal sentences. Any limitation must be prescribed by law and proportionate.

Practical Significance

In Tanzania, freedom of movement is relevant to: (a) the repatriation of refugees; (b) restrictions on persons on bail or under court supervision; (c) employment mobility across regions; and (d) freedom to move between mainland Tanzania and Zanzibar, which involves Union considerations.

Article 18 — Freedom of Expression

Article 18(1): “Every person has the freedom of expression and communication.” This protects:

  • The right to hold and express opinions without interference.

  • The right to seek, receive, and impart information and ideas.

  • The freedom of the press and other media.

Article 18(2): The exercise of this freedom “shall be exercised subject to conditions provided for by law for the purposes of — (a) preserving the rights and reputations of other persons; (b) protecting national security, public order, public health or morals; and (c) suppressing contempt of court and perjury.”

What This Means in Practice

Freedom of expression does not protect: (a) incitement to violence; (b) defamatory falsehoods about individuals; (c) seditious publications threatening national security; (d) contempt of court. However, the limitations must be proportionate — a law that criminalises all criticism of government goes beyond what is necessary for any of the listed purposes.

Media Freedom

The freedom of the press is protected as part of Article 18. Tanzanian legislation relevant to media includes the Electronic and Postal Communications Act (Cap. 306, R.E. 2016), the Media Services Act (Cap. 229, R.E. 2016 — replacing the former Newspaper Act), and the Cybercrimes Act (Cap. 432, R.E. 2016). Critics have argued that some provisions of these Acts impose disproportionate restrictions on media freedom, and constitutional challenges have been filed.

Article 19 — Freedom of Conscience and Religion

Article 19(1): “Every person has the right to freedom of conscience, thought, and religion.” This protects: (a) the right to hold any religious belief; (b) the right to change religion; (c) the right to worship privately and publicly; (d) the right to religious education; (e) freedom from being compelled to take part in religious ceremonies or religious instruction contrary to one’s beliefs.

Article 19(2): The freedom of religion is limited to the extent that religious practices that are “harmful to public order, morals, or health” can be regulated by law.

Tanzania’s Secular Status

Tanzania does not have an established state religion. The Constitution does not designate Islam or Christianity (the two dominant religions) as official religions. The government is expected to be neutral in religious matters. However, religion plays an enormous role in Tanzanian political and social life, and tensions between religious communities have occasionally created public order concerns.

Article 20 — Freedom of Association

Article 20(1): “Every person has the right to freely associate with other persons and to form associations and join them, including the right to form and join trade unions for the protection of his interests.”

Article 20(2): No person shall be compelled to join any association.

This right protects: political parties, trade unions, professional associations, civil society organisations, religious bodies, and informal community groups. The Political Parties Act (Cap. 258) regulates the registration and operation of political parties. A party that fails to meet registration requirements (e.g., support from every region of Tanzania) may be refused registration — but the refusal must not be arbitrary or discriminatory.

Article 21 — Right to Participate in Public Affairs

Article 21(1): “Every citizen of Tanzania has the right to participate in governance of the country, whether directly or through representatives freely elected by the people, in accordance with the law.”

Article 21(2): “Every citizen of Tanzania has the right to vote and to be voted for in any election in accordance with the law.”

This right is the foundation of Tanzania’s democratic system. It guarantees: (a) universal suffrage; (b) the right to stand for election; (c) the right to vote in secret; and (d) the right to equal political participation.

The Mtikila Constitutional Saga — Independent Candidates

The Mtikila litigation is the most important sequence of cases on political rights in Tanzania. It spans over two decades and ultimately reached the African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights.

Stage 1: HC 1993 — Mtikila Wins

In Civil Case No. 5/1993, Rev. Mtikila argued that requiring candidates for President and Parliament to be members of a registered political party (a requirement introduced by the Constitution and the Elections Act) violated Articles 20 and 21. Mwalusanya J agreed and declared the requirement unconstitutional. He held that every citizen has the right to participate in elections independently, without party membership.

Stage 2: Constitutional Amendment — Government Entrenches the Ban

In response, the government amended the Constitution in 1994 to explicitly require party membership for candidates. Since the Constitution is supreme, a constitutional provision cannot be declared unconstitutional — so Mtikila’s earlier victory was effectively reversed by the amendment.

Stage 3: CA 2009 — Court of Appeal Upholds the Ban

In Civil Appeal No. 45/2009, the Court of Appeal held that the constitutional amendment was valid. The ban on independent candidates was now part of the Constitution itself. Constitutional provisions cannot be challenged as unconstitutional — they can only be changed through the amendment procedure.

Stage 4: African Court 2013 — Tanzania Violates the African Charter

Undeterred, Mtikila and the Tanganyika Law Society took the case to the African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights (located in Arusha). In Application Nos. 009 and 011/2011 (Judgment delivered 14 June 2013), the African Court held:

  • Tanzania’s ban on independent candidates violated Articles 2, 3, 10 and 13(1) of the African Charter (equality, freedom of association, right to participate in government).

  • The African Court has jurisdiction to review national constitutional provisions for compliance with the African Charter — even provisions in the Constitution itself.

  • Tanzania was ordered to take all necessary constitutional and legislative measures to remedy the violations.

This was the first judgment on the merits by the African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights — a historic ruling with major implications for African constitutional law.

Important Case Law

CASE 1: Rev. Christopher Mtikila v. AG, Civil Case No. 5/1993 (HC, [1995] TLR 31)

Court: High Court of Tanzania

Year: 1993/1995

Facts: See above — Mtikila challenged the constitutional ban on independent candidates.

Decision: Mwalusanya J: the ban violated Articles 20 and 21. Every citizen has the right to stand for election independently.

Principle: Article 21 confers an individual right to participate in elections. Requiring party membership as a condition of candidature unduly restricts this right.

CASE 2: Tanganyika Law Society & Mtikila v. Tanzania, African Court App. Nos. 009 & 011/2011 (African Court, 2013)

Court: African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights, Arusha

Year: 2013

Facts: Tanzania’s Constitution, as amended, prohibited independent candidates. This provision was challenged as violating the African Charter.

Decision: The African Court held Tanzania had violated African Charter Articles 2, 3, 10 and 13(1). Ordered Tanzania to remedy the violation.

Principle: (1) National constitutional provisions are not immune from review by regional human rights courts. (2) The right to participate in governance (including as an independent candidate) is protected by international and regional human rights law. (3) This is the first African Court merits decision — a landmark in African human rights jurisprudence.

CASE 3: Mtikila v. Republic, Criminal Appeal No. 90/1992 (High Court)

Court: High Court of Tanzania

Year: 1992

Facts: Mtikila organised a public gathering without a police permit as required by the Police Force Ordinance (now Cap. 322). He argued the permit requirement violated his right of assembly under Article 20.

Decision: The court held that while Article 20 protects freedom of association and assembly, the requirement for advance police notification (not blanket prohibition) was a permissible limitation under Article 30(2) for purposes of public order.

Principle: Freedom of assembly can be regulated (not prohibited) in the interest of public order. Advance notification requirements are constitutional; blanket bans are not.

Quick Summary

  • Article 17: freedom of movement — right to live anywhere in Tanzania, leave and return.

  • Article 18: freedom of expression — speech, press, information; limited for national security, reputation, health.

  • Article 19: freedom of religion — no established state religion; harmful religious practices may be regulated.

  • Article 20: freedom of association — political parties, trade unions, civil society.

  • Article 21: right to participate in governance — universal suffrage, right to stand for election.

  • Mtikila saga: HC win (1993) → constitutional amendment reversing it → CA upholds amendment (2009) → African Court finds violation (2013).

Article 22 — Right to Work

Article 22(1): “Every person has the right to work and remuneration in accordance with the law.”

Article 22(2): Every citizen has the right to equal opportunity for work.

This right means that the government cannot arbitrarily prevent a person from working, pursuing a livelihood, or engaging in a profession. It does not mean that the government must provide a job to every person — it is a freedom right, not an entitlement right. However, it does mean that government-imposed barriers to employment (such as discriminatory licensing requirements or arbitrary dismissal of public servants) can be challenged constitutionally.

Relationship with Labour Law

The right to work in Article 22 is given more detailed content by the Employment and Labour Relations Act (Cap. 366, R.E. 2019), which governs employment contracts, unfair dismissal, minimum wages, and labour rights. A person dismissed from employment in violation of their constitutional right to work can bring both a labour dispute under Cap. 366 and a constitutional petition under Article 30(3).

Article 23 — Right to Just Remuneration

Article 23: “Every person who works has the right to just remuneration, and equal pay for equal work.”

This provision has two elements:

  • Just remuneration: wages must be fair, not exploitative.

  • Equal pay for equal work: a woman doing the same job as a man must receive the same pay. This is an equality right in the employment context.

In practice, the determination of “just remuneration” is a complex socio-economic question. Courts tend to defer to the legislature and executive on specific wage levels, but will intervene if wages are manifestly discriminatory or exploitative.

Article 24 — Right to Own Property

The Guarantee

Article 24(1): “Every person is entitled to own property, and has a right to the protection of his property held in accordance with the law.”

Article 24(2): “It shall be unlawful for any person to be deprived of his property for the purposes of nationalisation or any other purposes without the authority of law which makes provision for fair and adequate compensation.”

Components of Article 24

(a) Right to Own Property

Every person — Tanzanian citizen or not — can own property in Tanzania. This includes land, buildings, businesses, personal property, intellectual property, and contractual rights. The right applies to both individuals and legal persons (companies).

(b) Protection from Arbitrary Deprivation

Property can only be taken by the state for legitimate public purposes AND with fair and adequate compensation. This is the constitutional requirement of just compensation for compulsory acquisition. The three requirements are: (i) authority of law (there must be a valid Act of Parliament authorising the acquisition); (ii) public purpose; and (iii) fair and adequate compensation.

(c) “Fair and Adequate” Compensation

This phrase has generated significant litigation. What is “fair and adequate”? Tanzanian courts have held that compensation must reflect the market value of the acquired property. Symbolic, nominal, or delayed compensation does not satisfy the constitutional requirement.

Land Law and the Constitution

Land law in Tanzania is governed primarily by the Land Act (Cap. 113, R.E. 2019) and the Village Land Act (Cap. 114, R.E. 2019). Under these Acts, all land in Tanzania is public land held in trust by the President. Individual Tanzanians hold rights of occupancy (not freehold ownership in the English sense). The constitutional implications are:

  • A right of occupancy is “property” for purposes of Article 24 — it can be protected and compensated upon compulsory acquisition.

  • Eviction from land without compensation and without following the legal process violates Article 24.

  • The government cannot extinguish customary rights of occupancy without compensation.

Part II — Directive Principles (Non-Justiciable Rights)

While Articles 22–24 are enforceable, the following Part II provisions are aspirational and not enforceable:

  • Article 7: The government has a duty to manage the national economy in a way that promotes social welfare.

  • Article 8: The governance of Tanzania shall be based on the consent of the people, achieved through democratic elections.

  • Article 9: Various specific duties of the state — including to ensure all citizens receive education, equal opportunity, healthcare, and basic needs.

  • Article 10: The welfare of the people is the basis of the state’s authority.

  • Article 11: The state has a duty to promote social development.

These provisions cannot ground a constitutional petition on their own — they must be linked to an enforceable Part III right to be litigated.

Articles 25–28A — Duties of Citizens

The Bill of Rights is not one-sided — it also imposes duties on citizens:

  • Article 25: Every person has the duty to work. The Constitution reflects Tanzania’s historical socialist ethos.

  • Article 26: Every person has the duty to observe the Constitution and the laws of Tanzania, to safeguard national interests, and to protect public property.

  • Article 26(2): “Every citizen of Tanzania has the right and duty to report anyone who violates the Constitution or laws of Tanzania to the relevant authority.” This is the public interest reporting duty — and it is also the basis for public interest litigation.

  • Article 27: Duty to safeguard public property and combat wastage.

  • Article 28: Duty to defend Tanzania.

  • Article 28A: Duty to pay taxes.

Important Case Law

CASE 1: AG v. Lohay Akonaay & Another [1995] TLR 80 (Court of Appeal) — Property Rights Aspect

Court: Court of Appeal of Tanzania

Year: 1995

Facts: The government passed the Regulation of Land Tenure (Established Villages) Act 1992, which extinguished all customary rights of occupancy in designated village land and converted them into government-controlled rights, without payment of compensation. The respondents, village farmers, challenged this as a violation of Article 24.

Legal Issue: Is extinguishment of customary rights of occupancy without compensation a violation of Article 24?

Decision: The Court of Appeal held YES. (1) Customary rights of occupancy are “property” within the meaning of Article 24. (2) Extinguishing them without compensation violates Article 24(2). (3) The Act was void to the extent of its inconsistency with Article 24.

Principle: (1) Customary land rights are constitutionally protected property. (2) Compulsory acquisition of any form of property requires fair and adequate compensation. (3) This is the most important Tanzanian case on property rights and remains the leading authority. Memorise it.

CASE 2: Festo Balegele & 794 Others v. Dar es Salaam City Council [1991] TLR 94 (High Court) — Property Rights Aspect

Court: High Court of Tanzania

Year: 1991

Facts: The City Council demolished the petitioners’ houses without following due process or paying compensation.

Decision: Mwalusanya J held: local authority demolition without compensation and without due process violated Article 24. The constitutional right to property applies against local government as much as against the central government.

Principle: Government bodies at all levels must respect property rights. No government body can deprive citizens of property without legal authority and compensation.

Practical Scenario

The Tanzania National Roads Agency (TANROADS) begins construction of a highway through a village in Morogoro region. Fifty families have lived on the land for three generations under customary rights of occupancy. TANROADS offers compensation of TZS 500,000 per family — a fraction of the land’s market value. A community leader consults you. You would advise: (1) The families have property rights under Article 24(1) — customary rights of occupancy are “property” per Lohay Akonaay. (2) Compulsory acquisition requires fair and adequate compensation per Article 24(2). (3) TZS 500,000 per family is manifestly inadequate if the market value is significantly higher. (4) A constitutional petition in the High Court under Article 30(3) can seek: (a) an injunction to halt construction pending fair compensation; (b) a declaration that the offered compensation is unconstitutionally inadequate; and (c) an order directing TANROADS to pay fair market value.

Quick Summary

  • Article 22: right to work — freedom to pursue livelihood; not a guarantee of employment.

  • Article 23: right to just remuneration — fair wages; equal pay for equal work.

  • Article 24: right to own property — protected against compulsory acquisition without legal authority and fair compensation.

  • Part II (Arts. 7–11): Directive Principles — NOT enforceable; guide government policy only.

  • Articles 25–28A: citizen duties — work, obey the law, protect public property, pay taxes.

  • Key case: AG v. Lohay Akonaay [1995] — customary rights are constitutional property; no taking without compensation.

  • Key legislation: Land Act (Cap. 113), Village Land Act (Cap. 114), Employment and Labour Relations Act (Cap. 366).

The Limitation Clause — Article 30(2)

Rights are not absolute. Every modern constitution recognises that rights may sometimes need to be limited — for example, freedom of expression does not protect the right to incite violence. Article 30(2) is the limitation clause — it sets out when rights can be limited:

Article 30(2): “Nothing in this Part of this Constitution shall be construed as invalidating any existing law or prohibiting the enactment of any law or the doing of anything which is lawful under such law insofar as that law in question makes provision for the purpose of safeguarding the interests of defence, public safety, public order, public morality, public health, rural and urban development planning, the exploitation of minerals or other natural resources, or the development or utilisation of any other property in such manner as to promote the public benefit.”

In plain language: a law can restrict a fundamental right if the restriction is: (1) prescribed by a law (not just an executive decision), and (2) for one of the listed purposes — defence, public safety, public order, public morality, public health, land planning, mineral exploitation, or public benefit.

The Proportionality Requirement

However, it is not enough to cite one of these purposes. Tanzanian courts — following the liberal/purposive approach — also apply a proportionality test. The restriction must be: (a) rationally connected to the stated purpose, and (b) no more extensive than necessary to achieve that purpose. An overly broad restriction fails this test even if the purpose is legitimate.

Derogation During a State of Emergency (Articles 31–32)

What is a State of Emergency?

A state of emergency is a declaration by the President (under Article 32) that an emergency exists threatening the security, peace, or good order of Tanzania. During an emergency, the government is permitted to derogate from (i.e., temporarily suspend) certain fundamental rights, to deal with the emergency.

Article 32 — Declaration of State of Emergency

Article 32(1): “Notwithstanding any other provisions of this Constitution, where a declaration under the Emergency Powers Act is in force, Parliament may enact such laws as may be necessary for the purposes of dealing with the emergency, and any such law may for the purposes of the emergency derogate from the provisions of this Constitution to the extent specified in the declaration.”

Non-Derogable Rights — Article 31(2)

Even during a state of emergency, certain rights CANNOT be suspended:

  • The right to life (Article 14) — no one can be killed during an emergency without lawful justification.

  • Protection against torture, inhuman, or degrading treatment (Article 13(6)(e)).

  • Freedom from slavery and forced labour (Article 25(2)).

  • The prohibition on retrospective criminal legislation (nulla poena sine lege).

These are the irreducible core rights. No matter how serious the emergency, they cannot be taken away.

Horizontal Application of Rights (Third Party Effect)

The Bill of Rights applies directly against the government (vertical application). The question in Tanzania — as in many countries — is whether rights also apply between private persons (horizontal application). For example, can you invoke Article 13 (equality) against a private employer who discriminates?

The direct horizontal application of rights in Tanzania is not yet fully settled by the courts. However, many statutes (the Employment and Labour Relations Act Cap. 366; the Law of the Child Act Cap. 13) give effect to constitutional rights in private relationships, creating indirect horizontal application.

Test yourself

The Bill of Rights: Nature, Scope and Limitations Practice Quiz Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback

Take the quiz

Get the Full Constitutional Law Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Test yourselfThe Bill of Rights: Nature, Scope and Limitations Practice QuizTake the quiz