Legal Opinions templates

Sample Legal Opinion for Answering Law Exam Questions

A sample legal opinion showing how to answer problem questions in law exams: the issues, the law, its application and the conclusion.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • PDF & Word
On this page 5 sections
  1. What is a legal opinion in a law exam?
  2. What format should you use to answer a legal opinion question?
  3. How do you score high marks on a legal opinion question?
  4. What mistakes cost marks in a legal opinion answer?
  5. Sample Sample of legal opinion (For answering Questions) Format

In a law exam, a “legal opinion” question gives you a set of facts and asks you to advise a client. The examiner is testing whether you can spot every legal issue in the facts, state the correct law, apply it to those facts and reach a clear conclusion. It is the most common question format in Tanzanian LLB and Law School examinations, from Family Law to Land Law.

Use the IRAC structure with clear headings, as the sample does:

  1. FactsSummarise only the facts that matter legally, in short numbered points.
  2. IssuesState each legal question separately: “Whether Maria and Juma are presumed to be married under section 160 of the Law of Marriage Act.”
  3. Law applicableList the statutes (with chapter number and current revised edition) and the cases you will rely on.
  4. Arguments (application)Take each issue in turn. State the rule, then apply it to the facts. This is where most of the marks are.
  5. Conclusion and adviceAnswer each issue directly and tell the client what to do next.
  • Find every issue. The Maria and Juma facts raise more than whether she can end the relationship. They also raise the division of the house she mostly paid for, and custody and maintenance of Peter and Mary. A first-class answer deals with all three.
  • Apply, do not recite. After stating that section 160(1) needs two years’ cohabitation and a reputation as husband and wife, go back to the facts: eight years together, two children, and what the neighbours think.
  • Use authority correctly. The sample uses three verified cases well: John Kirakwe v Iddi Siko [1989] TLR 215 for the elements of the presumption, Hoka Mbofu v Pastory Mwijage [1983] TLR 286 on mere concubinage, and the Court of Appeal’s decision in Hemed S. Tamim v Renata Mashayo [1994] TLR 197 on the court’s power under section 160(2) to divide property even when the presumption is rebutted.
  • Cite the current law. The Law of Marriage Act is Cap. 29 R.E. 2019. Examiners notice old revised editions.
  • Give practical advice. Tell the client which forum to go to and what to prove. For example, check whether the dispute must first go to a Marriage Conciliation Board before a petition is filed.
  • Writing an essay on the topic instead of advising the client on the facts given.
  • Missing an issue the facts obviously raise, such as the property or the children.
  • Citing cases that do not exist or that you cannot name properly. A made-up citation costs more than no citation.
  • A conclusion that does not answer the question asked, or that sits on the fence.

For the substantive law, read Meaning, Types, Validity and Formation of Marriage and Separation, Reconciliation, and the Marriage Conciliation Board. To see how an opinion looks in practice, compare the advocate-to-client legal opinion sample.

The following is a sample legal opinion that you can refer to when you are tasked to write a legal opinion in response to a scenario question

Question

For the past 8 years, Maria has shared a residence with Juma, but they have not undergone a formal marriage ceremony. Despite not formalizing their union, the couple has welcomed two children, Peter (6) and Mary (3).

Maria reveals that prior to cohabiting, Juma, who practices Islam, had initially agreed to convert to Christianity for the purpose of a formal Christian marriage. However, as the years have passed, Juma has not fulfilled this commitment, leaving Maria feeling deceived. Their children, Peter and Mary, have been baptized and regularly participate in Christian services with their mother, while Juma remains steadfast in maintaining his original religious affiliation.

Maria is distressed by the situation, believing it to be an embarrassment to her devout Christian parents. They jointly own a house on land that Maria had purchased before their relationship began. Notably, approximately 90% of the construction costs for the house were covered by Maria, as Juma lacks formal employment.

In light of the unmet agreement and the strain on their relationship, Maria desires to end the union.

Write a concise legal opinion to Maria

NOTE; The answer provided below is for illustrative purposes only and does not represent an actual situation. The goal is to demonstrate how to construct a legal opinion when addressing scenario-based questions..

Answer

Facts

  • Maria and Juma have been living together for 8 years but have not undergone any formal marriage ceremony.

  • Before cohabiting, Juma, who is a Muslim, agreed to convert to Christianity for a formal Christian marriage ceremony with Maria.

  • Despite the initial agreement, Juma has not changed his religion as promised.

  • Maria and Juma have two children, Peter (6) and Mary (3).

  • The children have been baptized and regularly attend Christian services with Maria.

  • Maria purchased the house on land before the relationship began.

  • Approximately 90% of the construction costs for the house were incurred by Maria, as Juma has no formal employment.

  • Maria wants to end the relationship due to the unmet agreement regarding religious conversion.

Issue

  • Whether Maria can end the relationship?

Law Applicable

  • Law of Marriage Act [Cap. 29 R.E. 2019]

  • Precedents

    • John Kirakwe V Iddi Siko 1989 TLR 215 (HC)

    • Hoka Mbofu V Pastory Mwijage 1983 TLR 286 (HC) 

    • Hemed S Tamim V Renata Mashayo 1994 TLR 197 (CA)

Arguments

In Tanzania mainland, conjugal relationships are regulated by the Law of Marriage Act [Cap. 29 R.E. 2019]. Section 160 (1) of the act stipulates that if it is proven that a man and woman have cohabited for two years or more, acquiring a reputation as husband and wife, there is a rebuttable presumption that they were legally married.

Referring to the case of John Kirakwe V Iddi Siko 1989 TLR 215 (HC), three essential elements for establishing a presumption of marriage are identified: (a) cohabitation for over two years; (b) acquiring the reputation of being husband and wife; and (c) the absence of a formal marriage ceremony.

In Maria’s situation, elements (a) and (c) are evident, having lived with Juma for eight years without a formal marriage ceremony. Element (b) depends on the perception of your relationship by neighbors. If they view your cohabitation as that of a husband and wife, the marriage is presumed; otherwise, the presumption is rebutted.

However, as per Hoka Mbofu V Pastory Mwijage 1983 TLR 286 (HC), if there is no allegation of a presumption of marriage, section 160 of the Law of Marriage Act, 1971 cannot be invoked based solely on concubinage association. To terminate the relationship, Maria must assert a presumption of marriage through a formal application (petition) to the court, providing evidence of the conduct and circumstances of their relationship.

Even if the court rebuts the presumption, as seen in Hemed S Tamim V Renata Mashayo 1994 TLR 197 (CA), if the parties have lived together as husband and wife, acquired property, and the presumption is rebutted, the court, under section 160(2) of the Act, can still make consequential orders such as the dissolution of marriage, separation, and division of matrimonial property acquired during their relationship.

Conlcusion

In conclusion, considering the above discussion, Maria may pursue ending the relationship Juma.

Download this template

  • PDF ready to printPro
  • Word fully editableElite
Join NowAlready a member? Log in

Each copy carries your name for personal use.

Pakua template hii kwa PDF au Word.

Learn the law behind it

Download this templatePDF with Pro · Word with EliteJoin Now