Private International Law notes · Topic 1 of 17

Private International Law in Tanzania: Meaning, Sources and Application

What private international law (conflict of laws) means, its sources in Tanzania from the CPC and Cap. 8 to JALA s. 2(3), and how courts apply it, with SCOVA Engineering and Gharib Abdallah Juma v Kay Mlinga.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 16 min read

In short

Private international law, also called the conflict of laws, is the part of Tanzanian law a court uses when a private dispute has a foreign element. It answers three questions: can a Tanzanian court hear the case, which country’s law governs it, and will a foreign judgment or award be recognised and enforced here. Tanzania has no single code on it. The rules come from statutes such as the Civil Procedure Code and the Reciprocal Enforcement of Foreign Judgments Act, from English common law received through section 2(3) of JALA, and from Court of Appeal decisions.

On this page 10 sections
  1. What is private international law?
  2. How is private international law different from public international law?
  3. What three questions does private international law answer?
  4. What are the sources of private international law in Tanzania?
  5. How does a Tanzanian court apply private international law?
  6. Does private international law apply to conflicts inside Tanzania?
  7. Which key terms must you know?
  8. Exam focus: what do examiners test on the meaning and sources of private international law?
  9. Practice question: the Danish settlement and the Dar es Salaam guarantee
  10. Key takeaways

What is private international law?

Imagine an Italian company sells irrigation machines to a sugar estate in Morogoro, and Tanzanian companies guarantee payment. The guarantee says Italian law applies and that a court in Rome will hear any dispute. The money is not paid, so the Italian seller sues in Dar es Salaam. Can the High Court hear the case? Which law decides it: Italian or Tanzanian? Those are private international law questions, and they arose in a real Court of Appeal case you will meet below.

Private international law is the body of rules a Tanzanian court applies whenever a private dispute has a foreign element: a party, a contract, a marriage, a piece of property or a judgment connected to another legal system. Three points are worth fixing in your mind from the start:

  • It is Tanzanian law. Every country has its own private international law. A Tanzanian court decides a cross-border case using Tanzanian conflict rules, and those rules may point it to a foreign law.
  • It deals with private relationships: contracts, torts, marriage, divorce, property, succession, companies and judgments. It is not about relations between states.
  • “Foreign” can mean Zanzibar. Mainland Tanzania and Zanzibar keep separate laws in many fields, including land, so conflict questions also arise inside the United Republic.

How is private international law different from public international law?

Public international law governs relations between states and international organisations; private international law governs private disputes that cross borders, and each country makes its own. The table shows the difference.

Private international law Public international law
Who is involved Individuals, families, companies States and international organisations
Main sources Each country’s own statutes, case law and received law Treaties and customary international law
Typical question Is a marriage settlement signed in Denmark enforceable against land in Zanzibar? May Tanzania detain a foreign warship?
Who decides National courts, such as the High Court of Tanzania States, international courts and tribunals

The name is misleading: the subject is national law, not international law. That is why many judges and writers prefer the term conflict of laws. The two names mean the same thing.

What three questions does private international law answer?

Every conflict case turns on one or more of three questions: jurisdiction, choice of law, and recognition and enforcement. Learn to ask them in that order.

1. Jurisdiction: can a Tanzanian court hear the case?

In civil matters, jurisdiction comes from statute, mainly the Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2019. Parties to international contracts often add a choice-of-court clause. The Court of Appeal explained how such clauses work in SCOVA Engineering S.p.A. and Another v Mtibwa Sugar Estates Ltd and 3 Others, Civil Appeal No. 133 of 2017 (judgment of 12 March 2021).

Two Italian companies sued four Tanzanian companies in the High Court (Commercial Division) for about EUR 1.28 million for irrigation machines. The guarantee and indemnity agreement chose Italian law and gave the Court of Rome “exclusive jurisdiction”. The High Court held that the clause ousted its jurisdiction and dismissed the suit. The Court of Appeal held:

  • The High Court’s jurisdiction is statutory, so the parties cannot oust it by agreement.
  • Choice-of-law and choice-of-forum clauses are nevertheless valid. They do not offend public policy or section 28 of the Law of Contract Act, Cap. 345.
  • An exclusive jurisdiction clause simply chooses one competent court. It does not take jurisdiction away from other competent courts.
  • The appellants were bound by their choice of Rome, so the High Court was right not to hear the case. But it was wrong to dismiss the suit without hearing the merits. The proper order was a stay, which respects the parties’ choice while keeping the suit alive.

You will study this in depth in Jurisdiction of Tanzanian Courts in Cross-Border Civil Cases.

2. Choice of law: which country’s law governs?

Once the court has jurisdiction, it must find the law that governs the issue, called the lex causae. Conflict rules do this through connecting factors, links between an issue and a legal system:

  • Contracts: the law the parties chose or, failing that, the law most closely connected with the contract. Older cases speak of the law of the place of contracting (lex loci contractus).
  • Land and other immovables: the law of the place where the property is (lex situs).
  • Personal status and capacity: traditionally the law of the person’s domicile (lex domicilii).
  • Procedure: always the law of the court hearing the case (lex fori).

The Court of Appeal at Zanzibar used several of these in Gharib Abdallah Juma v Kay Mlinga, Civil Appeal No. 10 of 2001, [2002] TZCA 10; [2004] T.L.R. 74 (Makame, Ramadhani and Mroso, JJ.A.). The appellant, a Zanzibari living in Denmark, married the respondent, a Tanzanian from the Mainland, in Denmark in 1984. Two days before the wedding they signed a Danish marriage settlement. It kept his Copenhagen flat as his separate property and otherwise created “complete community of property”. After a judicial separation and divorce in Denmark, she sued in the High Court of Zanzibar for a share of houses he owned in Zanzibar.

  • Validity of the settlement: the Court accepted that its validity depended on the law of the place where it was made (Denmark), and there was no evidence that it was invalid under Danish law. A Zanzibar rule on consideration did not apply, because it governed agreements made in Zanzibar.
  • Scope: only the Copenhagen flat was excluded, so the community of property covered the Zanzibar houses too.
  • Land: rights in immovable property are governed by the lex situs. Under section 8(1) of the Zanzibar Land Tenure Act, 1992, only a Zanzibari may own land in Zanzibar, and the constitutional right to property in Article 24 does not override the statutory conditions on how that right is exercised. The respondent had not shown that she had become a Zanzibari.
  • Result: instead of a share of the land itself, she was entitled to the money value of her share, assessed by a Government Valuer. The appeal substantially failed.

One case, three connecting factors: the place of contracting for the settlement, the lex situs for the land, and the forum’s own rules on who may hold land. That is private international law in action.

3. Recognition and enforcement: will a foreign judgment work here?

Winning a judgment abroad is of little use if the debtor’s assets are in Tanzania and the judgment cannot be enforced here. Tanzania has two main routes:

  • Registration under the Reciprocal Enforcement of Foreign Judgments Act, Cap. 8 R.E. 2019. Judgments from countries to which Part II of the Act has been extended, by order listing those countries, can be registered in the High Court on application under the Act and its Rules. Once registered, the judgment is enforced like a judgment of the High Court under the Civil Procedure Code.
  • A fresh suit on the judgment. A judgment from a country outside the Act usually has to be enforced by suing on it in a Tanzanian court. The Civil Procedure Code guides the court: section 11 states when a foreign judgment is not conclusive, and section 12 sets out a presumption as to foreign judgments.

Foreign arbitral awards follow a separate route under the Arbitration Act, Cap. 15. Both routes are covered in Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Judgments in Tanzania and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards in Tanzania.

What are the sources of private international law in Tanzania?

Tanzania has no Private International Law Act. You build the rules from five sources: statutes, received English law, Tanzanian case law, international conventions given effect by statute, and the leading textbooks.

1. Statutes

Statute What it does for conflict of laws
Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2019 Jurisdiction and place of suing; when a foreign judgment is conclusive (ss. 11 and 12)
Reciprocal Enforcement of Foreign Judgments Act, Cap. 8 R.E. 2019, and its Rules Registration of judgments from reciprocating countries
Evidence Act, Cap. 6 Proof of foreign law through expert opinion and official books of foreign law
Arbitration Act, Cap. 15 Recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards
Law of Marriage Act, Cap. 29 Marriages and matrimonial proceedings with a foreign element
Probate and Administration of Estates Act, Cap. 352 Estates with assets or grants in more than one country
Law of Contract Act, Cap. 345 R.E. 2023 Section 28 (agreements restraining legal proceedings), which SCOVA held does not invalidate choice clauses
Judicature and Application of Laws Act, Cap. 358 R.E. 2019 Receives English common law (s. 2(3)) and governs the internal choice between customary, Islamic and general law (ss. 9 and 11)

A practical note on the Evidence Act: in the R.E. 2019 text, section 47 (opinions of experts) covers cases where the court must form an opinion on a point of foreign law, and section 40 makes relevant statements of foreign law in books published under the authority of the foreign government. In the text consolidated on TanzLII to 31 December 2023, the expert-opinion provision appears as section 52. Always check the current section number before you cite it. Proof of foreign law is covered in Proving Foreign Law in Tanzanian Courts.

2. Received English law

The core conflict rules on domicile, characterisation, renvoi and the proper law of a contract are judge-made English rules. They apply in Tanzania through section 2(3) of the Judicature and Application of Laws Act, which receives the common law, the doctrines of equity and the statutes of general application in force in England on 22 July 1920, so far as local circumstances permit. That is why classic English cases such as Udny v Udny (1869) on domicile and Re Annesley [1926] Ch 692 on renvoi appear throughout these notes.

3. Tanzanian case law

Decisions of the Court of Appeal, such as SCOVA Engineering and Gharib Abdallah Juma, bind the High Court and subordinate courts, and show how the received rules apply to Tanzanian facts. Reported conflict decisions are still relatively few, so in exams and practice you will often pair a Tanzanian authority with a leading English one.

4. International conventions

Treaties bind Tanzanian courts only when they are given effect by domestic law. The clearest example in this subject is the enforcement of foreign arbitral awards, which works through the Arbitration Act.

5. Textbooks

Works such as Cheshire, North and Fawcett: Private International Law and Dicey, Morris and Collins on the Conflict of Laws are persuasive, not binding. Courts use them to state the received common law rules.

How does a Tanzanian court apply private international law?

A court deciding a case with a foreign element works through the same sequence every time. Use it as the structure for your problem answers:

  1. Spot the foreign element. Which party, act, property or judgment connects the case to another legal system?
  2. Jurisdiction. Does the court have jurisdiction under the Civil Procedure Code? Is there a choice-of-court or arbitration clause (SCOVA)?
  3. Characterise the issue. Is it contract, tort, succession, marriage or procedure? The category decides the connecting factor. See Characterisation (Classification) in Private International Law.
  4. Apply the connecting factor to find the lex causae: domicile, lex situs, the chosen law, and so on. See Domicile in Private International Law.
  5. Prove the foreign law. A Tanzanian court does not take judicial notice of foreign law. It is a question of fact, proved by evidence, usually expert evidence.
  6. Check for exclusions. The court will not apply foreign law that offends Tanzanian public policy, or enforce foreign penal or revenue laws. See When Tanzanian Courts Refuse Foreign Law.
  7. Recognition. If a foreign judgment or award is involved, decide whether it can be registered or sued on.

Does private international law apply to conflicts inside Tanzania?

Yes. The same reasoning works within the United Republic in two ways.

  • Mainland and Zanzibar. Zanzibar has its own courts and its own laws in many fields, including land, contract and registration of documents. Gharib Abdallah Juma came from the High Court of Zanzibar and turned on the Zanzibar Land Tenure Act and Zanzibar decrees. The Reciprocal Enforcement of Foreign Judgments Act is expressed as an Act for enforcement between Mainland Tanzania and foreign countries.
  • Customary, Islamic and general law. Deciding which personal law governs a marriage or an estate is an internal conflict of laws. Section 11 of JALA governs when customary law applies to matters of a civil nature, and section 9 governs the application of Islamic law. The method is the one you use internationally: connect the person or transaction to the right system of law.

Which key terms must you know?

  • Foreign element: a fact connecting the case to another legal system.
  • Lex fori: the law of the court hearing the case.
  • Lex causae: the law that governs the issue.
  • Connecting factor: the link used to choose the law, such as domicile, the situation of property or the parties’ choice.
  • Lex situs: the law of the place where property is situated.
  • Lex loci contractus: the law of the place where a contract was made.
  • Lex domicilii: the law of a person’s domicile.
  • Characterisation: deciding which legal category an issue belongs to.
  • Renvoi: where the foreign law’s own conflict rules refer the case back to Tanzanian law or on to a third law. See The Doctrine of Renvoi.

Exam focus: what do examiners test on the meaning and sources of private international law?

  • Define the subject in one sentence and name the three questions. Then show the method.
  • Never write that Tanzania “has no private international law”. Say it has no single code, then list the statutes and section 2(3) of JALA.
  • Explain why English cases are authoritative here: the 22 July 1920 reception date, subject to local circumstances.
  • Use SCOVA Engineering for any choice-of-court clause: stay, not dismissal.
  • Use Gharib Abdallah Juma for foreign marriage settlements, lex loci contractus and lex situs.

Practice question: the Danish settlement and the Dar es Salaam guarantee

Question: Neema, a Tanzanian working in Norway, signs a contract in Oslo to buy equipment from a Norwegian company. Her brother in Mwanza guarantees payment. The guarantee chooses Norwegian law and the Oslo courts. Neema defaults, and the company sues the brother in the High Court at Mwanza. Advise the brother.

  1. Issue: can the High Court hear the claim, and what is the effect of the Oslo clause?
  2. Rule: jurisdiction is statutory and cannot be ousted by agreement, but a choice-of-court clause is valid and binding (SCOVA Engineering).
  3. Application: the brother should apply for a stay, relying on the parties’ choice of Oslo. The court will not dismiss the suit unheard. If the case stays in Tanzania, Norwegian law, as the chosen law, governs the guarantee and must be proved as a fact.
  4. Conclusion: the likely outcome is a stay in favour of the Oslo courts.

Key takeaways

  • Private international law (conflict of laws) is Tanzanian domestic law for private disputes with a foreign element.
  • It answers three questions: jurisdiction, choice of law, and recognition and enforcement.
  • Its sources are statutes (CPC, the Reciprocal Enforcement of Foreign Judgments Act, the Evidence Act, the Arbitration Act and others), English law received through s. 2(3) of JALA, Tanzanian case law, conventions given effect by statute, and textbooks.
  • SCOVA Engineering: choice-of-court clauses are valid and bind the parties, but do not oust statutory jurisdiction; the right order is a stay.
  • Gharib Abdallah Juma: a foreign marriage settlement is judged by the law of the place where it was made, while land is governed by the lex situs.
  • Conflict reasoning also applies inside Tanzania, between Mainland and Zanzibar law and between customary, Islamic and general law.

Key Statutes and Cases on Private International Law in Tanzania: Meaning, Sources and Application

Statutes

  • Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2019ss. 11 and 12 (foreign judgments)
  • Reciprocal Enforcement of Foreign Judgments Act, Cap. 8 R.E. 2019Registration of judgments of reciprocating countries
  • Judicature and Application of Laws Act, Cap. 358 R.E. 2019s. 2(3) reception of English law; ss. 9 and 11 Islamic and customary law
  • Evidence Act, Cap. 6Expert opinion on foreign law (s. 47 R.E. 2019); books of foreign law (s. 40)
  • Law of Contract Act, Cap. 345 R.E. 2023s. 28

Cases

  • SCOVA Engineering S.p.A. and Another v Mtibwa Sugar Estates Ltd and 3 Others, Civil Appeal No. 133 of 2017 (CAT, 12 March 2021)Choice-of-court clause binds the parties but does not oust jurisdiction; stay, not dismissal
  • Gharib Abdallah Juma v Kay Mlinga, Civil Appeal No. 10 of 2001, [2002] TZCA 10; [2004] T.L.R. 74Danish marriage settlement judged by lex loci contractus; Zanzibar land governed by lex situs

Test yourself

Private International Law in Tanzania: Meaning, Sources and Application Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback

Take the quiz

Get the Full Private International Law Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Test yourselfPrivate International Law in Tanzania: Meaning, Sources and ApplicationTake the quiz