In short
A case theory is a short, persuasive account of what happened and why the law entitles your client to win. It combines a legal theory (the cause of action or defence and its elements) with a factual theory (a story, consistent with the evidence, that satisfies each element) and a theme (one memorable idea that explains the story). Everything at trial, from which witnesses you call to every question in cross-examination and every line in submissions, should serve the case theory. Trial preparation turns the theory into a plan: an elements chart, a proof plan for each element, witness and exhibit lists, anticipated objections, and a trial notebook. In the Law School’s oral and written assessments, the student with a clear theory almost always outperforms the student who simply reacts.
On this page 4 sections
This module uses two files from earlier modules: Neema Mushi v Kilimo Bora Ltd, a civil debt claim from the Civil Procedure and Practice module, and Republic v Baraka Mollel, the stealing by servant case from the Criminal Procedure and Practice module. For background skills, read Court Presentation and Professionalism.
How do you build a case theory?
- List the elementsFrom the law: for Neema’s claim, a contract, delivery of the maize, the price due, non-payment. For Baraka’s defence, the prosecution must prove every ingredient of stealing by servant.
- Map the evidence to each elementWhich witness or document proves (or disproves) each element? Where are the gaps?
- Identify the facts you cannot changeBad facts do not go away. Your theory must explain them.
- Write the story in three sentencesWho your client is, what happened, and why that means she wins.
- Find the themeOne phrase the court will remember: “Kilimo Bora took the maize and kept the money.” “Four cashiers, one password, no proof.”
- Test itArgue the other side’s theory against yours. If yours cannot answer it, revise.
Key Statutes and Cases on Case Theory and Trial Preparation
Statutes
- Evidence Act, Cap. 6 R.E. 2023Proof and burden
- Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2023Civil trial
- Criminal Procedure Act, Cap. 20 R.E. 2023Criminal trial
Test yourself
Case Theory and Trial Preparation Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
