Legal Writing and Drafting notes · Topic 5 of 18

Legal Essays and Academic Legal Writing

Learn how to write clear, structured legal essays using statutes, cases, and critical analysis for law school exams and assignments.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 7 min read
On this page 17 sections
  1. Introduction to Legal Essays and Academic Legal Writing
  2. Meaning of a Legal Essay
  3. Purpose of Legal Essays in Legal Education
  4. Understanding the Essay Question
  5. Identifying the Subject Matter
  6. Identifying the Command Words
  7. Identifying the Scope of the Question
  8. Structure of a Legal Essay
  9. The Introduction
  10. The Body of the Essay
  11. Example of Integrating Legal Authority
  12. Developing a Legal Argument
  13. Integrating Legal Authorities
  14. Academic Integrity and Plagiarism
  15. Practical Example of Legal Essay Analysis
  16. Practical Exam Tips for Legal Essays
  17. Key Takeaways for Law Students

Legal essays are one of the most important forms of assessment in law school. Through legal essays, students demonstrate their:

  • Knowledge of the law

  • Ability to analyse legal issues

  • Skill in constructing logical arguments

  • Capacity to apply legal authorities such as statutes and cases

In Tanzanian law schools, legal essays are used in:

  • Coursework assignments

  • Take-home examinations

  • Written examinations

  • Research papers and dissertations

A good legal essay does more than describe the law. It evaluates legal rules, questions their effectiveness, and applies them to legal problems.

In simple terms, a legal essay answers the question:

What is the law, how does it operate, and should it operate that way?

Therefore, legal writing is the beginning of legal reasoning and legal thinking.


Definition of a Legal Essay

A legal essay is a structured piece of academic writing that:

  • Analyses a legal question or problem

  • Uses legal authorities such as statutes and cases

  • Develops a logical argument

  • Reaches a justified conclusion

A legal essay must therefore combine:

  • Legal knowledge

  • Logical reasoning

  • Critical analysis


Legal essays are designed to test several essential skills of a law student.

Key Skills Tested

  1. Understanding the law

Students must demonstrate knowledge of statutes and case law.

For example:

  • Law of Contract Act, Cap 345 R.E. 2022

  • Law of Torts

  • Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania 1977

  1. Legal reasoning

Students must show how legal rules apply to issues.

  1. Analytical ability

Students must evaluate whether legal rules are:

  • Fair

  • Effective

  • Logical

  1. Legal research

Students must support arguments with legal authorities such as:

  • Statutes

  • Case law

  • Academic commentary


Understanding the Essay Question

One of the biggest mistakes students make is misunderstanding the essay question.

Before writing, students should carefully analyse the question.

Why Understanding the Question is Important

Essay questions are carefully constructed by examiners.

Every word in the question helps define:

  • The legal issue

  • The scope of the discussion

  • The required method of answering

Failure to interpret the question correctly may result in writing irrelevant answers.


Identifying the Subject Matter

The first step is identifying the area of law being tested.

Examples include:

  • Contract Law

  • Tort Law

  • Constitutional Law

  • Criminal Law

  • Administrative Law

Example

Essay question:

“Critically analyse the doctrine of consideration under Tanzanian contract law.”

Here the subject matter is:

Contract Law, specifically consideration.

The relevant statute would be:

  • Law of Contract Act, Cap 345


Identifying the Command Words

Command words tell the student what type of answer the examiner expects.

Discuss

This requires a balanced analysis.

Students must present:

  • Different views

  • Legal authorities

  • Evaluation of the issue

Critically Analyse

This requires deeper evaluation.

Students must:

  • Examine strengths and weaknesses

  • Consider opposing arguments

  • Reach a justified conclusion

Examine

This requires a detailed exploration of the topic.

Students must analyse the legal principles thoroughly.

Explain

This requires a clear description of the law.

Students should focus on:

  • Legal rules

  • Statutory provisions

  • Case law

Compare and Contrast

This requires identifying:

  • Similarities

  • Differences

Example:

Test yourself

Legal Essays and Academic Writing Quiz Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free

Take the quiz

Get the Full Legal Writing and Drafting Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Keep reading this topicFrom TSh 5,000 a weekJoin Now