Legal System of East Africa notes · Topic 6 of 10

Definition, Nature, and Application of Customary Law

Explains customary law, its features, court application, conflicts, and constitutional challenges in Tanzania.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 5 min read
On this page 13 sections
  1. Introduction to Customary Law
  2. Meaning and Definition of Customary Law
  3. Key Characteristics of Customary Law
  4. Proof and Ascertainment of Customary Law in Court
  5. The Repugnancy Clause
  6. Post-Independence Position in Tanzania
  7. Codification vs Restatement of Customary Law
  8. Conflict of Customary Laws
  9. Customary Law and Constitutional Rights
  10. Key Case Law
  11. Practical Illustrations
  12. Exam Tips and Key Takeaways
  13. Final Summary

Introduction to Customary Law

Customary law is one of the primary sources of law in Tanzania, alongside statutory law and common law.

To understand the Tanzanian legal system fully, you must appreciate that law did not begin with colonial rule. Long before written statutes, African communities regulated themselves through customs.

These customs developed into what we now call customary law.


Meaning and Definition of Customary Law

General Definition

Customary law refers to:

  • A body of rules, practices, and usages

  • Developed over time within a community

  • Accepted as binding rules of conduct

In simple terms:

Customary law is the law that comes from the way people have always lived and accepted as right.


Statutory Definition in Tanzania

The Interpretation and General Clauses Act (Cap. 1 R.E. 2002) defines customary law as:

“Any rule or body of customary rules regulating rights and imposing correlative duties, or a customary rule or body of rules which obtain and are fortified by established usage.”

Explanation of the Definition

Let’s break this down:

  • “Rule or body of rules” → Customary law is structured, not random behavior

  • “Regulating rights and duties” → It creates legal relationships

  • “Fortified by established usage” → It must be widely practiced and accepted over time


Key Characteristics of Customary Law

Understanding these characteristics is essential for exams.

1. Unwritten Nature

Customary law is:

  • Not originally written down

  • Passed through oral tradition and practice

However, note:

  • Some parts are now recorded or codified, especially in Tanzania

Example:
Marriage customs in a village may be known by elders but not written in any statute.


2. Dynamic and Living Law

Customary law is not static.

  • It changes with society

  • It adapts to modern realities

Courts recognize this principle.

Key Judicial View:
Courts in East Africa have emphasized that customary law must reflect current social conditions, not outdated practices.

Illustration:
A custom that once excluded women from inheritance may evolve due to modern views on equality.


3. Community-Specific

There is no single African customary law.

  • Each ethnic group has its own rules

  • Tanzania has over 120 ethnic communities

Example:

  • Haya customary law differs from Chagga customary law

  • Sukuma marriage customs differ from Maasai customs


4. Personal Application

Customary law mainly governs:

  • Marriage

  • Divorce

  • Succession (inheritance)

  • Family relations

It does not usually apply to:

  • Commercial transactions

  • Constitutional law

  • Criminal law (mostly governed by statutes)


Proof and Ascertainment of Customary Law in Court

Because customary law is largely unwritten, courts must prove its existence and content.

1. Judicial Notice

Courts may recognize customary law without proof if:

  • It is well-known

  • It has been applied in previous cases

Key Idea:
The court says: “We already know this custom.”


2. Expert Evidence

Courts may rely on:

  • Elders

  • Chiefs

  • Anthropologists

  • Legal experts

These individuals explain the custom as expert witnesses.

Example:
An elder may testify on how inheritance works in a particular tribe.


3. Use of Assessors

Courts may sit with assessors, who are:

  • Respected community members

  • Knowledgeable in customary law

Important:

  • Their role is advisory only

  • The judge is not bound by their opinion


4. Reference to Codified or Restated Law

Where customary law has been written:

  • Courts may refer directly to those texts

Example in Tanzania:

  • Customary Law (Declaration) Order, 1963


The Repugnancy Clause

Meaning of the Repugnancy Clause

This was a colonial legal principle stating that:

Customary law would only apply if it was:

  • Not repugnant to justice and morality, and

  • Not inconsistent with written law


Historical Origin

One of the earliest examples:

  • Uganda Order in Council, 1902


Effect of the Repugnancy Clause

This clause had major consequences:

  • Gave colonial judges power to reject African customs

  • Imposed European moral standards

  • Led to distortion of true customary law

Examples of customs rejected:

  • Widow inheritance

  • Levirate marriage

  • Traditional punishments


Scholarly Criticism

Legal scholars like Martin Chanock argue:

  • What courts applied was not true customary law

  • It was a colonial reconstruction, often biased toward:

    • Male elders

    • Colonial interests


Post-Independence Position in Tanzania

Abolition of the Repugnancy Clause

Tanzania removed the clause through:

  • Magistrates’ Courts Act, 1963

Current Legal Position

Today, customary law is valid only if it complies with:

  • The Constitution of Tanzania (1977)

  • Written laws

This reflects the principle of constitutional supremacy.


Codification vs Restatement of Customary Law

Codification (Tanzania’s Approach)

Tanzania adopted codification, meaning:

  • Customary law was written into binding legal rules

Example:

  • Customary Law (Declaration) Order, 1963

Effects:

  • Provides certainty

  • Easier for courts to apply

Criticism:

  • Freezes law in time

  • Prevents natural evolution

  • May misrepresent actual customs


Restatement (Kenya’s Approach)

Kenya used restatement, notably by:

  • Eugene Cotran (1968–1969)

Features:

  • Not legally binding

  • Serves as a guide

Advantage:

  • Allows flexibility

  • Courts can adapt to change


Conflict of Customary Laws

The Problem

Tanzania has many ethnic groups → conflicts arise when:

  • Parties come from different communities

Example:
A Chagga man marries a Luo woman — which law applies?


Rules Developed by Courts

Courts apply the following principles:

1. Husband’s Law Rule

  • In patrilineal societies, the husband’s customary law governs:

    • Marriage

    • Property

    • Succession


2. Agreement of Parties

  • Parties may choose which customary law applies


3. Neutral Approach

Where no clear rule exists:

  • Courts apply:

    • Common principles between systems, or

    • Statutory law


Customary Law and Constitutional Rights

This is one of the most important modern exam topics.

The Core Issue

Some customary practices conflict with:

  • Equality

  • Human rights

  • Non-discrimination


Problematic Practices

Examples include:

  • Male primogeniture

  • Widow disinheritance

  • Restrictions on women owning land

  • Polygamy (in some contexts)


Key Case Law

Ephrahim v Pastory (1990) – Tanzania

Facts:

  • Under Haya customary law, women could not sell clan land

Decision:

  • The High Court (Mwalusanya J.) declared the rule unconstitutional

Legal Principle Established:

  • Customary law must comply with the Bill of Rights (1984 Amendment)

  • Gender discrimination is invalid

Importance:

This case confirms:

The Constitution overrides customary law


Rono v Rono (2005) – Kenya

Issue:

  • Male primogeniture in inheritance

Holding:

  • The court questioned its compatibility with equality principles

Significance:

  • Reinforces the idea that:

    • Customary law must align with modern constitutional values


Practical Illustrations

Example 1: Marriage

A couple marries under customary law:

  • Bride price is paid

  • Elders witness the union

This marriage is legally recognized under customary law.


Example 2: Inheritance Dispute

A man dies without a will:

  • Family applies customary rules

  • Eldest son claims all property

Court may intervene if:

  • The rule discriminates against daughters


Exam Tips and Key Takeaways

  • Always define customary law using both general and statutory definitions

  • Mention key characteristics (unwritten, dynamic, community-based, personal)

  • Explain methods of proof (judicial notice, experts, assessors)

  • Discuss the repugnancy clause and its abolition in Tanzania

  • Distinguish between codification and restatement

  • Highlight constitutional supremacy over customary law

  • Always cite Ephrahim v Pastory (1990) in gender equality questions


Final Summary

Customary law remains a vital part of Tanzania’s legal system, especially in personal matters.

However, its application today is shaped by:

  • The Constitution

  • Statutory law

  • Judicial interpretation

The modern approach ensures that:

Customary law continues to exist — but only in a way that respects justice, equality, and human rights.

Test yourself

Customary Law in Tanzania Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free

Take the quiz

Get the Full Legal System of East Africa Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Test yourselfCustomary Law in TanzaniaTake the quiz