On this page 12 sections
- Introduction to Advocacy Ethics
- Ethical Position of Defence Counsel in Criminal Practice
- Duties of the Prosecutor as Minister of Justice
- Treatment of Complainants and Victims
- Ethical Conduct in Bail Applications
- Ethics in Capital Cases
- Ethical Conduct in Civil Litigation
- Settlement Ethics
- Ethics in Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)
- Ethics in Negotiation
- Important Distinctions for Exams
- Exam Tips and Key Takeaways
Introduction to Advocacy Ethics
Advocacy ethics refers to the professional and moral duties that guide advocates when representing clients in court and other legal processes.
In Tanzania, these duties arise from:
-
The Advocates Act, Cap. 341
-
The Tanganyika Law Society Rules of Professional Conduct
-
The Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania, 1977
-
Court decisions (case law)
Ethics ensures that:
-
Justice is fairly administered
-
Courts are not misled
-
Clients are properly represented
-
Public confidence in the legal system is maintained
We will now examine advocacy ethics in two key areas:
-
Criminal practice
-
Civil practice and Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)
Ethical Position of Defence Counsel in Criminal Practice
Meaning and Core Principle
One of the most important — and often misunderstood — principles is this:
An advocate may represent a client they know is guilty.
This principle is fundamental to the adversarial system of justice.
Constitutional Foundation
Under the Constitution of Tanzania (1977), particularly Article 13, every accused person has the right to:
-
Be presumed innocent
-
A fair trial
-
Legal representation
-
Be convicted only upon proof beyond reasonable doubt
These rights apply regardless of actual guilt.
Role of Defence Counsel
The advocate’s role is not to prove innocence, but to:
-
Ensure the State proves its case lawfully
-
Protect the rights of the accused
-
Prevent wrongful conviction
What Defence Counsel May Do
An advocate may:
-
Represent the accused in court
-
Challenge admissibility of evidence
-
Cross-examine prosecution witnesses
-
Test credibility of witnesses
-
Argue that the prosecution has not proved its case
-
Raise legitimate defences such as:
-
Self-defence
-
Provocation
-
Alibi
-
What Defence Counsel Must NOT Do
An advocate must never:
-
Present evidence they know is false
-
Allow the client to lie under oath knowingly
-
Fabricate a defence
-
Coach witnesses to give false testimony
-
Suborn perjury
-
Assert innocence as a fact when they know the client is guilty
Key Distinction
There is a critical difference between:
-
Saying: “My client is innocent” (not allowed if known false)
-
Saying: “The prosecution has failed to prove its case” (allowed)
Case Insight
R v McCarthy (1924)
Established that justice must not only be done but must be seen to be done — highlighting the importance of fair defence.
Practical Example
If a client confesses guilt privately:
-
You still defend them
-
But you cannot call them to lie in court
-
You focus on whether the prosecution proves the case
Duties of the Prosecutor as Minister of Justice
Meaning of Prosecutor’s Role
A prosecutor represents:
-
The Republic (State)
-
Not a private client
Test yourself
Advocacy Ethics in Practice Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
