Criminal Law notes · Topic 5 of 10

Attempts and Conspiracy

Clear and exam-focused explanation of attempt and conspiracy under the Penal Code with cases and illustrations.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 4 min read
On this page 21 sections
  1. Introduction to the Topic
  2. Meaning of Attempt
  3. Elements of Attempt
  4. Preparation vs Attempt
  5. Case Law on Attempt
  6. Attempt in Theft Cases
  7. Attempted Murder
  8. Attempted Rape
  9. Impossibility in Attempt
  10. Why Attempt is Punished
  11. Specific Offences of Attempt
  12. Meaning of Conspiracy
  13. Elements of Conspiracy
  14. Key Principle
  15. Features of Conspiracy
  16. Case Law
  17. Special Rules in Conspiracy
  18. Practical Example
  19. Important Distinctions
  20. Exam Approach
  21. Key Takeaways

Introduction to the Topic

In criminal law, some offences are punished even before they are completed. These are called inchoate offences.

The two main inchoate offences are:

  • Attempt

  • Conspiracy

These offences are important because they allow the law to punish individuals who show a clear intention to commit crimes—even if the crime is not fully completed.

The main statutory provisions include:

  • Section 380 Penal Code – Attempt

  • Section 382 Penal Code – Punishment for attempt

  • Section 386 Penal Code – Conspiracy

Meaning of Attempt

Definition

An attempt is:

👉 An act done with intent to commit a crime, forming part of a series of acts which would result in the commission of that crime if not interrupted.

Key Idea

  • The law does not punish mere intention

  • There must be some action beyond preparation

Elements of Attempt

To prove attempt, the prosecution must establish:

Mens Rea (Guilty Mind)

  • The accused must have intended to commit the specific offence

  • Mere recklessness is not enough

Actus Reus (Guilty Act)

  • There must be an overt act

  • The act must go beyond preparation

  • The act must be proximate to the commission of the offence

Preparation vs Attempt

Preparation

  • Acts done to get ready for committing a crime

  • Not punishable

Example:

  • Buying poison to kill someone

Attempt

  • Acts that directly move towards committing the offence

  • Punishable

Example:

  • Putting poison into someone’s drink

Key Test

👉 Has the accused begun execution of the crime?

Case Law on Attempt

R v Robinson [1915] 2 KB 342

The accused staged a fake burglary to claim insurance but had not yet contacted the insurer.

Held: this was only preparation, not attempt.

Significance:
There must be a step directly connected to the offence.

Attempt in Theft Cases

Key Principle

There must be asportation (movement of property).

Ambokile Mwamalongo v Republic (1967) H.C.D. No. 275

The accused partially removed a purse from the victim’s pocket.

Held: sufficient movement → attempt proved.

Kombo Abdaraman v Republic [1980] T.L.R. 90

The accused tried to put his hand into the victim’s pocket but failed.

Held: attempt established because execution had begun.

Attempted Murder

Legal Requirement

Under section 211 Penal Code, the prosecution must prove:

👉 Intention to kill, not merely intention to cause harm

Case Law

R v Christopher Ngambilo (1967) H.C.D. No. 388

The accused shot the victim in the knee.

Held: no attempted murder—no proof of intent to kill.

R v Rukondo Kamaro (1968) H.C.D. No. 48

Accused shot arrows from a distance.

Held: only grievous harm, not attempted murder.

Exam Tip

Always distinguish:

  • Murder → intention to kill OR cause grievous harm

  • Attempted murder → intention to kill only

Attempted Rape

Legal Requirement

Under section 132 Penal Code, the prosecution must prove:

  • intention to have sexual intercourse

  • intention to do so despite resistance

Case Law

Mulira v Republic (1953) 20 E.A.C.A. 223

The accused undressed and assaulted the victim but fled when she screamed.

Held: not attempted rape → only assault with intent

Omar v Republic (1971) H.C.D. No. 362

The accused tore clothes but did not proceed further.

Held: indecent assault, not attempted rape

Modern Approach

R v Andrew Avarity (1973) L.R.T No. 92

The court moved away from strict technical rules.

Held:

  • Focus on intention

  • Look at overt acts

  • Do not over-emphasize “proximity”

Key Principle

If:

  • intention is clear, and

  • overt acts are proven

👉 attempt is established

Impossibility in Attempt

Rule

Under section 380 Penal Code:

👉 Impossibility is NOT a defence

Types of Impossibility

Factual Impossibility

  • Crime cannot be completed due to unknown facts

Example:

  • Trying to steal from an empty pocket

👉 Still liable

Legal Impossibility

  • The act is not actually a crime

👉 No liability

Case Law

Edward Michael v Republic (1948) 1 T.L.R. 308

The accused tried to sell fake diamonds believing they were real.

Held: guilty of attempt

Reason: intention + overt act = liability

Key Principle

👉 The court looks at what the accused believed he was doing

Why Attempt is Punished

The law punishes attempts because:

  • The accused shows dangerous intention

  • He is willing to break the law

  • Society must be protected early

Specific Offences of Attempt

Examples under the Penal Code:

  • Section 211 – Attempted murder

  • Section 132 – Attempted rape

  • Section 150 – Attempted abortion

  • Section 287 – Attempted robbery

  • Section 320 – Attempted arson

  • Section 382 – General punishment

Meaning of Conspiracy

Definition

A conspiracy is:

👉 An agreement between two or more persons to:

  • commit an unlawful act, OR

  • commit a lawful act by unlawful means

Elements of Conspiracy

Agreement

  • The core element

  • Must be between two or more persons

Unlawful Objective

  • The agreement must aim at something illegal

Intention

  • Each conspirator must intend to carry out the plan

Key Principle

👉 The crime is complete once there is agreement

No further act is required.

Features of Conspiracy

  • No need for direct communication

  • Members may join at different times

  • Each need not know full details

  • Even small participation is sufficient

Case Law

R v Karia (1949) 16 E.A.C.A. 116

The accused conspired to export diamonds illegally.

Held: conspiracy can be inferred from conduct.

Ogodia & Erima v Uganda [1967] E.A. 137

Conspiracy to set up a roadblock.

Held: agreement can be inferred even without direct proof.

Special Rules in Conspiracy

One person cannot conspire alone

At least two persons are required.

If one conspirator is acquitted

  • Others may also be acquitted

  • Unless conspiracy with unknown persons is proved

Exception

A person can be convicted:

  • even if others are unknown, dead, or absent

Practical Example

If A and B agree to rob a bank:

  • They are guilty of conspiracy immediately

  • Even if the robbery never happens

Important Distinctions

Attempt vs Conspiracy

Attempt

Conspiracy

Focus on action

Focus on agreement

Requires overt act

No act required

Individual liability

Joint liability

Preparation vs Attempt

Preparation

Attempt

Not punishable

Punishable

Remote acts

Proximate acts

Exam Approach

For Attempt Questions

  • Identify intention

  • Identify overt act

  • Distinguish preparation vs execution

  • Apply section 380

For Conspiracy Questions

  • Identify agreement

  • Identify participants

  • Identify unlawful purpose

  • Apply section 386

Key Takeaways

  • Attempt requires intention + overt act

  • Mere preparation is not enough

  • Impossibility is not a defence

  • Attempted murder requires intent to kill

  • Conspiracy is complete upon agreement

  • Even minimal participation can lead to liability

  • Courts focus on intention and conduct

Test yourself

Attempts and Conspiracy Practice Quiz Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback

Take the quiz

Get the Full Criminal Law Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Test yourselfAttempts and Conspiracy Practice QuizTake the quiz