Contract Law notes · Topic 4 of 18

Vitiating Factors in Contract Law

Factors that destroy free consent in contracts under Tanzanian law, including coercion, undue influence, fraud, misrepresentation, and mistake.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 9 min read
On this page 34 sections
  1. Introduction to Vitiating Factors in Contract Law
  2. Meaning of Vitiating Factors
  3. Vitiating Factors under Tanzanian Law
  4. Coercion (Duress)
  5. Meaning of Coercion
  6. Forms of Duress
  7. Elements of Coercion
  8. Case Law: Barton v Armstrong (1975)
  9. Legal Consequences of Coercion
  10. Undue Influence
  11. Meaning of Undue Influence
  12. Statutory Definition
  13. Situations Where Undue Influence May Occur
  14. Elements of Undue Influence
  15. Practical Illustration
  16. Case Law: Tate v Williamson (1866)
  17. Legal Consequences
  18. Fraud
  19. Meaning of Fraud
  20. Statutory Definition
  21. Elements of Fraud
  22. Case Law: Derry v Peek (1889)
  23. Silence and Fraud
  24. Remedies for Fraud
  25. Misrepresentation
  26. Meaning of Misrepresentation
  27. Statutory Definition
  28. Types of Misrepresentation
  29. Case: Smith v Hughes (1871)
  30. Difference Between Fraud and Misrepresentation
  31. Mistake
  32. Meaning of Mistake
  33. Types of Mistake
  34. Key Exam Takeaways

Introduction to Vitiating Factors in Contract Law

In contract law, one of the most important requirements for a valid contract is free consent.

For a contract to be legally binding, the parties must freely agree to the same thing in the same sense. Lawyers describe this using the Latin phrase consensus ad idem, which means meeting of the minds.

This principle is recognized under Section 13 of the Law of Contract Act, Cap 345 R.E. 2023, which states that:

Two or more persons are said to consent when they agree upon the same thing in the same sense.

However, sometimes consent is not truly free. A person may be pressured, deceived, misled, or mistaken when entering a contract.

When such situations occur, the law says that consent has been affected by a vitiating factor.

Meaning of Vitiating Factors

A vitiating factor is a circumstance that undermines or destroys the validity of consent in a contract.

When a vitiating factor exists:

  • The agreement may become void or voidable

  • The affected party may avoid the contract

  • The court may provide legal remedies

In simple terms, vitiating factors protect parties from unfair, dishonest, or oppressive agreements.

Vitiating Factors under Tanzanian Law

The Law of Contract Act, Cap 345 R.E. 2023, specifically recognizes vitiating factors.

According to Section 14 of the Law of Contract Act, consent is said to be free when it is not caused by:

  • Coercion

  • Undue influence

  • Fraud

  • Misrepresentation

  • Mistake

If consent is caused by any of these factors, the contract may not be valid.

We will now examine each of these factors one by one.


Coercion (Duress)

Meaning of Coercion

Coercion occurs when a person is forced or pressured into entering a contract through threats or unlawful acts.

The law does not recognize agreements made under intimidation or threats as genuine consent.

Statutory Definition

Section 10 of the Law of Contract Act defines coercion as:

Committing or threatening to commit any act forbidden by the Penal Code, or unlawfully detaining or threatening to detain property, with the intention of causing any person to enter into an agreement.

In simple words, coercion involves forcing someone to agree by threatening them or their property.

Forms of Duress

Pressure leading to coercion may take different forms:

  • Physical threats (violence or bodily harm)

  • Economic pressure

  • Threats against property

  • Psychological pressure

Elements of Coercion

For coercion to be established, the following elements must exist:

1. Illegitimate Pressure

The pressure must involve an unlawful act or improper threat.

Examples include:

  • Threatening violence

  • Threatening to commit a crime

  • Unlawfully detaining property

2. Causation

The threat must have caused the victim to enter the contract.

The victim must show that the agreement was made because of the threat.

3. No Reasonable Alternative

The victim must have had no reasonable option except agreeing.

If a person had a safe alternative but still agreed voluntarily, coercion may not be established.

Case Law: Barton v Armstrong (1975)

Facts

Armstrong threatened to kill Barton if he did not sign a contract relating to the sale of shares.

Decision

The Privy Council held that the contract was entered under duress.

Principle Established

A contract is voidable if threats contributed to the decision to enter the contract, even if there were other reasons.

This case demonstrates that serious threats invalidate genuine consent.

Under Section 19(1) of the Law of Contract Act, a contract induced by coercion is voidable.

This means the victim has two options:

  • Rescind the contract (cancel it), or

  • Affirm the contract (continue with it)

If the contract is rescinded:

  • Both parties must return any benefits received

  • The parties are restored to their original positions


Undue Influence

Meaning of Undue Influence

Undue influence occurs when one party uses a position of trust or authority to unfairly influence another person to enter into a contract.

Unlike coercion, undue influence does not involve threats or illegal acts. Instead, it involves abuse of trust or power.

Statutory Definition

Under Section 16 of the Law of Contract Act, a contract is induced by undue influence where:

One party is in a position to dominate the will of the other and uses that position to obtain an unfair advantage.

Situations Where Undue Influence May Occur

Undue influence commonly arises in relationships involving trust and dependence, such as:

  • Parent and child

  • Doctor and patient

  • Advocate and client

  • Religious adviser and follower

  • Guardian and ward

In such relationships, the dominant party may manipulate the weaker party.

Elements of Undue Influence

To prove undue influence, the following elements must exist:

1. Relationship of Trust and Confidence

One party must be in a position of influence over the other.

2. Dominance of Will

The dominant party must have the ability to control or influence the decision of the weaker party.

3. Unfair Advantage

The dominant party must have obtained an unfair benefit through the transaction.

Practical Illustration

Suppose a magistrate presides over a criminal case involving a contractor.

The magistrate tells the contractor:

“Reduce the contract price, and I will acquit you.”

Because the magistrate has authority over the case, the contractor may feel compelled to accept the unfair deal.

This is a clear example of undue influence, because the magistrate abuses his position.

Case Law: Tate v Williamson (1866)

Facts

A young man facing financial difficulties asked his uncle for advice on selling property.

The uncle bought the property for £7,000, even though he knew it was worth £20,000, and he did not disclose this information.

Decision

The court set aside the transaction.

Principle Established

Where a relationship of trust exists, the dominant party must act honestly and disclose material information.

Failure to do so may amount to undue influence.

Under Section 19 of the Law of Contract Act, a contract induced by undue influence is voidable.

The influenced party may:

  • Rescind the contract, or

  • Affirm the contract


Fraud

Meaning of Fraud

Fraud occurs when one party intentionally deceives another party in order to induce them to enter a contract.

Fraud involves dishonesty and deliberate deception.

Statutory Definition

According to Section 17 of the Law of Contract Act, fraud includes:

  • Making a false statement knowingly

  • Making a statement without believing it to be true

  • Making a statement recklessly without caring whether it is true or false

Elements of Fraud

For fraud to be established, the following elements must exist:

1. False Representation

There must be a false statement of fact.

2. Knowledge of Falsity

The person making the statement knows it is false.

3. Intent to Deceive

The statement must be made with the intention of misleading the other party.

4. Reliance

The victim must rely on the false statement when entering the contract.

5. Resulting Damage

The victim must suffer loss or harm because of the deception.

Case Law: Derry v Peek (1889)

Facts

A company issued a prospectus stating it had the right to operate steam-powered trams, subject to government approval.

The approval was never granted.

Decision

The court held that fraud requires proof of dishonesty.

Principle Established

A statement is fraudulent only if it is made:

  • Knowing it is false

  • Without belief in its truth

  • Recklessly

This case established the legal test for fraud.

Silence and Fraud

Generally, silence does not amount to fraud.

However, there are exceptions.

Exceptions Where Silence May Be Fraud

Silence may amount to fraud when:

  • There is a duty to disclose information

  • Silence is intended to deceive

  • A half-truth creates a misleading impression

  • There is a change of circumstances

Case: With v O’Flanagan (1930)

A doctor selling his medical practice stated that the business earned £2,000 per year.

Later his income dropped due to illness, but he did not inform the buyer.

The court held that failure to disclose the change was fraudulent.

Remedies for Fraud

Under Sections 19 and 64 of the Law of Contract Act, the victim of fraud may:

  • Rescind the contract, or

  • Insist on performance as if the representation were true

  • Claim damages


Misrepresentation

Meaning of Misrepresentation

Misrepresentation occurs when a false statement of fact is made that induces another party to enter a contract, even though there may be no intention to deceive.

Statutory Definition

According to Section 18 of the Law of Contract Act, misrepresentation includes:

  • Making a false statement believed to be true

  • Breach of duty that misleads another party

  • Causing a party to make a mistake about the subject matter of the contract

Types of Misrepresentation

Fraudulent Misrepresentation

A false statement made knowingly or recklessly.

The victim may:

  • Rescind the contract

  • Claim damages

Negligent Misrepresentation

Occurs when a statement is made without reasonable grounds for believing it to be true.

Important case:

Hedley Byrne v Heller (1964)
Established liability for negligent misrepresentation where a special relationship exists.

This principle was confirmed in:

Esso Petroleum v Mardon (1976).

Innocent Misrepresentation

Occurs where a statement is false but made honestly.

The remedy is usually rescission of the contract, but not damages.

Case: Smith v Hughes (1871)

Facts

A buyer purchased oats believing they were old oats, suitable for horse feed.

The seller made no representation about the oats’ age.

Decision

The court held that there was no misrepresentation, because the seller made no false statement.

Principle

Misrepresentation requires an actual false statement, not merely a mistaken assumption.


Difference Between Fraud and Misrepresentation

Although fraud and misrepresentation both involve false statements, they differ mainly in intent.

Fraud

  • Involves intentional deception

  • Requires proof of dishonesty

  • Victim may claim rescission and damages

Misrepresentation

  • May occur innocently or negligently

  • Does not require intent to deceive

  • Remedy may be rescission only


Mistake

Meaning of Mistake

Mistake occurs when one or both parties enter a contract based on an incorrect belief about an important fact.

Mistake must relate to a fact, not law.

The law follows the maxim:

Ignorantia juris non excusat
(Ignorance of the law is no excuse).

Therefore:

  • Mistake of fact may affect a contract

  • Mistake of law does not

Types of Mistake

Unilateral Mistake

Provided under Section 22 of the Law of Contract Act.

This occurs when only one party is mistaken.

Example:

A seller mistakenly believes land is residential, but it is actually commercial.

If the other party knowingly takes advantage of the mistake, the contract may be challenged.

Common Mistake

Recognized under Section 20(1) of the Law of Contract Act.

A common mistake occurs when both parties share the same mistaken belief about a fundamental fact.

Example:

Both parties contract to sell goods believed to exist, but the goods had already been destroyed.

The contract becomes void.

Case: Galloway v Galloway (1914)

The parties entered a separation agreement believing they were legally married.

Later it was discovered the marriage was invalid.

The court held that the agreement was void due to common mistake.

Mutual Mistake

Occurs when both parties misunderstand each other and therefore there is no consensus ad idem.

Case: Hartog v Colin & Shields (1939)

The seller mistakenly quoted a price per pound instead of per piece.

The buyer knew this was an error.

The court held the contract void, because there was no meeting of the minds.

Mistake as to Document (Non Est Factum)

The Latin term non est factum means:

“It is not my deed.”

It is a defence used when a person signs a document fundamentally different from what they believed they were signing.

Case: Foster v Mackinnon (1869)

An elderly man was tricked into signing a bill of exchange, believing it was a guarantee.

The court allowed the defence of non est factum.

He was therefore not bound by the document.


Key Exam Takeaways

Students should remember the following points:

1. Free consent is essential for a valid contract.

2. Section 14 of the Law of Contract Act lists five vitiating factors:

  • Coercion

  • Undue influence

  • Fraud

  • Misrepresentation

  • Mistake

3. Most vitiated contracts are voidable, meaning the injured party may rescind or affirm the contract.

4. Fraud requires proof of intention to deceive, while misrepresentation may occur without such intention.

5. Mistake must generally be a mistake of fact, not law.

Understanding vitiating factors is crucial because they determine whether a contract is enforceable or can be avoided in law.

Test yourself

Vitiating Factors in Contract Law Quiz Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback

Take the quiz

Get the Full Contract Law Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Test yourselfVitiating Factors in Contract Law QuizTake the quiz