On this page 7 sections
Introduction to Discharge of Contracts
In contract law, parties enter into agreements with the expectation that obligations will be fulfilled. However, contracts do not last forever. At some point, the obligations created by the contract must come to an end.
The legal process through which contractual obligations are terminated is known as discharge of a contract.
A contract is said to be discharged when the parties are released from their contractual obligations. After discharge, the parties are no longer required to perform their promises under the contract.
Understanding how contracts are discharged is very important because it helps determine:
-
When parties are no longer bound by a contract
-
Whether a party has committed a breach
-
Whether remedies such as damages are available
Under Tanzanian law, particularly the Law of Contract Act, Cap. 345 R.E. 2023, contracts may be discharged in several ways.
The main methods of discharge are:
-
Discharge by performance
-
Discharge by agreement
-
Discharge by frustration (supervening impossibility)
-
Discharge by breach
Each of these methods will be explained step-by-step.
Discharge by Performance
Meaning of Discharge by Performance
Discharge by performance occurs when both parties completely fulfill their contractual obligations.
This is the normal and intended way in which contracts end.
Once the parties have performed everything they promised, the contract naturally comes to an end and no further obligations remain.
Example
Suppose:
-
A contracts to sell 100 bags of rice to B for TZS 5,000,000.
-
A delivers the rice.
-
B pays the agreed price.
Once both parties perform their obligations, the contract is discharged by performance.
The Rule of Exact Performance
The general rule in contract law is that performance must be complete and exact.
This means:
-
The party must perform all obligations exactly as agreed.
-
Partial performance is normally not sufficient.
This rule was established in the English case:
Cutter v Powell
Facts
A sailor agreed to work on a ship from Jamaica to Liverpool for a lump sum payment payable only after completion of the voyage. He died before reaching Liverpool.
Decision
The court held that his estate could not claim any payment because the contract required complete performance.
Legal Principle
If a contract requires complete performance, partial performance does not entitle the party to payment unless the contract provides otherwise.
Exception: Substantial Performance
Courts recognize that in some situations, a party may perform almost all obligations, but with minor defects.
In such situations, the doctrine of substantial performance applies.
Under this doctrine:
-
If a party has substantially performed the contract,
-
They may still recover the contract price,
-
But the amount payable may be reduced to compensate for defects.
The leading authority is:
Hoenig v Isaacs
Facts
A decorator agreed to decorate and furnish a flat for a fixed price. The work was completed but contained minor defects.
Decision
The court held that the decorator had substantially performed the contract and was therefore entitled to payment minus the cost of correcting the defects.
Principle
Substantial performance allows recovery of the contract price subject to deductions for incomplete or defective work.
Illustration
A contractor agrees to construct a house according to agreed specifications.
-
The house is completed
-
But a different brand of tiles is used
Test yourself
Discharge of Contracts Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
