On this page 13 sections
- Introduction to General Defences in Tort Law
- Overview of General Defences
- Volenti Non Fit Injuria (Consent)
- Inevitable Accident
- Act of God (Vis Major)
- Private Defence (Self-Defence and Defence of Others)
- Statutory Authority
- Necessity
- Illegality (Ex Turpi Causa Non Oritur Actio)
- Mistake
- Key Distinctions Between Defences
- Practical Problem Illustration
- Exam Tips and Key Takeaways
Introduction to General Defences in Tort Law
In tort law, even where a claimant (plaintiff) proves all elements of a tort, the defendant may still avoid or reduce liability by relying on defences.
These defences are divided into:
-
Complete defences → completely eliminate liability
-
Partial defences → reduce the amount of damages
General defences apply across multiple torts such as negligence, nuisance, and trespass.
Overview of General Defences
The main general defences include:
-
Volenti non fit injuria (consent)
-
Inevitable accident
-
Act of God (vis major)
-
Private defence (self-defence and defence of others)
-
Statutory authority
-
Necessity
-
Illegality (ex turpi causa non oritur actio)
-
Mistake
Let us now study each defence step-by-step.
Volenti Non Fit Injuria (Consent)
Meaning and Definition
The Latin maxim “volenti non fit injuria” means:
“To a person who consents, no harm is done.”
This defence applies where the plaintiff freely agrees to accept the risk of harm, thereby waiving the right to sue.
Key Elements
To succeed, the defendant must prove:
-
The plaintiff had full knowledge of the risk
-
The plaintiff voluntarily accepted the risk
-
The plaintiff accepted both:
-
The physical risk, and
-
The legal risk (waiving the right to sue)
-
Important:
👉 Knowledge alone is NOT consent
Key Case
Smith v. Baker & Sons [1891] AC 325 (HL)
-
Facts: A worker continued working under a crane lifting stones overhead. He knew the risk.
-
Held: The House of Lords held that knowledge of risk is not consent.
-
Principle: Employees often do not have a real choice → defence rarely succeeds in employment cases.
Limits of the Defence
-
Difficult to apply in employment relationships
-
Does not apply if:
-
Risk exceeds what was agreed
-
Consent was not freely given
-
-
May be excluded by statute
Example
A spectator at a football match accepts the risk of being hit by the ball.
But if organisers are negligent (e.g., no safety barriers), volenti may fail.
Inevitable Accident
Meaning
An inevitable accident is:
An accident that could not have been prevented even with reasonable care and skill.
It removes liability by showing no negligence occurred.
Key Features
-
No intention to cause harm
-
No negligence
-
Accident unavoidable despite precautions
Key Case
Stanley v. Powell [1891] 1 QB 86
Test yourself
General Defences in Tort Law Practice Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
