Intellectual Property Law notes · Topic 3 of 8

Copyright Infringement, Exceptions and Remedies

When copyright is infringed in Tanzania: primary and secondary infringement, copying a substantial part, online piracy, the fair use exceptions for private use, education, criticism, news and libraries, civil remedies (injunctions, damages, account, delivery up and Anton Piller orders), criminal offences, and COSOTA enforcement.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 10 min read

In short

Copyright is infringed when a person, without the owner’s authorisation, does an act reserved to the owner, such as reproducing, distributing, performing, broadcasting or adapting the work or a substantial part of it, or deals commercially in infringing copies. Cap. 218 allows limited free uses (fair use), including private use, quotation, teaching, news reporting and library copying. Owners can obtain injunctions, damages or an account of profits, delivery up and seizure of infringing copies, and serious infringement, especially commercial piracy, is a criminal offence. COSOTA and the police enforce, and courts can grant Anton Piller search orders to preserve evidence.

On this page 8 sections
  1. What amounts to infringement?
  2. What are the exceptions (fair use)?
  3. What civil remedies are available?
  4. What are the criminal consequences?
  5. How is online infringement handled?
  6. Exam focus
  7. Practice question: the photocopy kiosk
  8. Key takeaways

What amounts to infringement?

  • Primary infringement: doing any restricted act without consent: copying a book, uploading a film, playing recorded music in a bar without a licence, or translating a novel.
  • Substantial part: copying need not be complete. The question is whether what was taken is a substantial part, judged by quality, not quantity (Ladbroke v William Hill [1964] 1 WLR 273; Designers Guild v Russell Williams [2000] 1 WLR 2416). A short, distinctive hook of a song can be enough.
  • Proof of copying: similarity plus access to the original raises an inference of copying; independent creation is a defence.
  • Secondary infringement: importing, selling, hiring out or distributing copies the person knows or has reason to believe are infringing.
  • Circumvention: removing technological protection or rights management information may also be unlawful.

What are the exceptions (fair use)?

  • Reproduction for private personal use.
  • Quotation, with acknowledgement, to the extent justified by the purpose.
  • Use for teaching and examinations, within fair practice.
  • Reporting current events, and reproduction of speeches and lectures delivered in public for news purposes.
  • Reproduction by libraries and archives for preservation and research.
  • Uses for judicial proceedings.
  • The use must be fair, the source acknowledged where required, and must not conflict with normal exploitation of the work or unreasonably prejudice the owner (the three-step test in Berne and TRIPS).
  • Photocopying a whole textbook for sale to students is not fair use.

What civil remedies are available?

  1. Injunction: temporary and permanent, to stop the infringement. Temporary injunctions follow the Atilio v Mbowe test; see Equitable Remedies.
  2. Damages: compensation for loss, possibly including additional damages for flagrant infringement.
  3. Account of profits: the infringer’s gains, as an alternative to damages.
  4. Delivery up and destruction of infringing copies and equipment.
  5. Search order (Anton Piller): where there is a real risk that evidence will be destroyed, the court may order the defendant to allow the claimant’s lawyers to enter, search for and seize evidence (Anton Piller v Manufacturing Processes [1976] Ch 55).

What are the criminal consequences?

  • Making, selling, hiring, importing or possessing for sale infringing copies, or performing works in public without authority for commercial purposes, are offences under Cap. 218, punishable by fines, imprisonment, or both, and forfeiture.
  • The penalty provisions were strengthened by amendments in 2019, including changes to s. 42 and a new s. 42A; check the current text for amounts.
  • COSOTA inspectors, with the police, raid pirate distributors and unlicensed users.

How is online infringement handled?

  • Uploading or streaming works without permission is infringement of the right of communication to the public.
  • Electronic and Postal Communications (Online Content) Regulations and platform takedown procedures allow rights holders to request removal of infringing material.
  • Evidence should be captured early (screenshots with dates, URLs, download records).

Exam focus

  • Elements of infringement and substantial part.
  • Fair use exceptions and their limits.
  • Civil and criminal remedies, including Anton Piller.

Practice question: the photocopy kiosk

Question: A kiosk near a university photocopies entire law textbooks and sells bound copies to students. A lecturer also posts a full chapter of a textbook on a public website for her class. Advise the publisher.

  1. Kiosk: commercial reproduction and sale of whole books is infringement and an offence; fair use does not apply.
  2. Remedies: injunction, damages or account, delivery up, and criminal complaint through COSOTA and police.
  3. Lecturer: teaching use may be fair only within limits; posting a full chapter publicly goes beyond fair practice. Request takedown and license a closed platform.

Key takeaways

  • Infringement covers copying a substantial part, judged by quality.
  • Fair use is narrow and must not harm normal exploitation.
  • Remedies include injunctions, damages, account and search orders.
  • Commercial piracy is a crime.

Key Statutes and Cases on Copyright Infringement, Exceptions and Remedies

Statutes

  • Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Act, Cap. 218Infringement; limitations and exceptions (private use, quotation, teaching, news reporting, libraries and archives); civil remedies; offences and penalties (s. 42, amended in 2019, and s. 42A)
  • Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33Injunctions and interlocutory orders

Cases

  • Designers Guild Ltd v Russell Williams (Textiles) Ltd [2000] 1 WLR 2416Substantial part judged by quality
  • Ladbroke (Football) Ltd v William Hill (Football) Ltd [1964] 1 WLR 273Quality, not quantity, of what is taken
  • Anton Piller KG v Manufacturing Processes Ltd [1976] Ch 55Search orders to preserve evidence

Test yourself

Copyright Infringement, Exceptions and Remedies Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback

Take the quiz

Get the Full Intellectual Property Law Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Test yourselfCopyright Infringement, Exceptions and RemediesTake the quiz