Alternative Dispute Resolution notes · Topic 2 of 11

Negotiation and Settlement Agreements

Negotiation as a form of ADR in Tanzania: styles, BATNA, when a settlement is binding, the without-prejudice rule, registration under CPC Part V, Walford v Miles, and multi-tier clauses after Hodi v Jandu Plumbers.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 8 min read

In short

Negotiation is the parties (or their advocates) bargaining directly to settle a dispute, with no neutral third person. It is the cheapest and most flexible form of ADR. A settlement reached by negotiation is binding only if it satisfies the Law of Contract Act, Cap. 345 (offer, acceptance, consideration, free consent and lawful object). Parties may register a settlement in a competent court under Part V of the Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33, and in a pending suit the court can record it and pass a consent decree. At common law, a bare agreement to negotiate is too uncertain to enforce (Walford v Miles [1992] 2 AC 128), but a clearly defined negotiation step in a dispute clause can be a condition precedent to arbitration.

On this page 8 sections
  1. What is negotiation?
  2. What are the main negotiation styles?
  3. When is a negotiated settlement binding?
  4. Are agreements to negotiate enforceable?
  5. What is the advocate's role in negotiation?
  6. Exam focus: what do examiners test on negotiation?
  7. Practice question: the unpaid contractor
  8. Key takeaways

What is negotiation?

Negotiation is a voluntary process in which the parties communicate directly to reach an agreement. There is no neutral, no fixed procedure and no imposed outcome. You will meet it everywhere: before suits are filed, during mediation, and even during trials.

  • Advantages: fast, private, cheap and fully in the parties’ control; preserves relationships.
  • Disadvantages: power imbalances can produce unfair deals; there is no one to break a deadlock; a party may use talks only to delay.

What are the main negotiation styles?

Style How it works Risk
Positional (distributive) Each side takes a position and concedes slowly; a fixed “pie” is divided. Deadlock and damaged relationships.
Interest-based (principled) Parties look behind positions to underlying interests, generate options and use objective criteria. Takes more time and trust.
Competitive versus cooperative Competitive negotiators aim to win; cooperative ones seek joint gains. Mismatched styles can exploit the cooperative party.

A key planning tool is the BATNA (best alternative to a negotiated agreement): what you will do if talks fail, such as suing or arbitrating. A negotiator should not accept a deal worse than the BATNA.

When is a negotiated settlement binding?

  • Contract law applies: a settlement is a contract and must meet the requirements of the Law of Contract Act, Cap. 345, including free consent. A settlement induced by coercion, undue influence, fraud or misrepresentation is voidable.
  • “Without prejudice” talks: statements made in genuine settlement negotiations are generally not admissible as admissions in later proceedings, which encourages frank discussion. A concluded settlement, however, can be proved.
  • Writing: write the settlement down, sign it, and state clearly that it settles all claims in the dispute.
  • Registration: under CPC Part V, parties who settle by conciliation, negotiation or mediation may register the settlement in a court of competent jurisdiction.
  • In a pending suit: the court records the compromise and passes a decree in its terms; see Court-Annexed Mediation and Reconciliation in Tanzanian Courts.

Are agreements to negotiate enforceable?

  • Bare agreement to negotiate: in Walford v Miles [1992] 2 AC 128, the House of Lords held that an agreement to negotiate in good faith is unenforceable because it lacks certainty; a party may withdraw from negotiations at any time.
  • Dispute resolution clauses: courts will enforce an ADR step if the clause is sufficiently certain, setting out a defined process (Cable & Wireless plc v IBM United Kingdom Ltd [2002] EWHC 2059 (Comm)).
  • Multi-tier clauses in Tanzania: where a contract requires negotiation or mediation before arbitration, skipping the step can deprive the arbitrator of jurisdiction. In M/S Hodi (Hotel Management) Co. Ltd v M/S Jandu Plumbers Ltd, Civil Appeal No. 396 of 2022, [2025] TZCA 138, the Court of Appeal upheld the setting aside of an award because the contract’s pre-arbitration mediation step (a mediator’s written opinion) had not been completed. See The Arbitral Tribunal: Appointment, Removal and Jurisdiction.

What is the advocate’s role in negotiation?

  • Obtain clear instructions and authority before making or accepting offers.
  • Advise the client on the BATNA, costs, risks and time of litigation.
  • Act honestly; an advocate must not mislead the other side about material facts.
  • Draft the settlement carefully, including payment terms, default clauses, confidentiality, and withdrawal of any pending suit.

Exam focus: what do examiners test on negotiation?

  • Definition, features, advantages and disadvantages.
  • Positional versus interest-based negotiation and BATNA.
  • When a settlement is binding: contract law, without-prejudice rule and registration under CPC Part V.
  • Walford v Miles, Cable & Wireless v IBM and multi-tier clauses (Hodi v Jandu Plumbers).

Practice question: the unpaid contractor

Question: A contractor and a district council sign a contract saying disputes “shall first be negotiated in good faith by senior officers for 30 days, and if unresolved, referred to arbitration”. The contractor files for arbitration the day after a dispute arises. Advise the council.

  1. The clause sets a defined negotiation step with a time limit, so it is sufficiently certain to be a condition precedent (Cable & Wireless v IBM).
  2. Skipping it may mean the arbitrator lacks jurisdiction, following the reasoning in Hodi v Jandu Plumbers.
  3. The council should object to the tribunal’s jurisdiction no later than its first step on the merits (Arbitration Act, s. 35), or it may lose the right to object (s. 80).

Key takeaways

  • Negotiation is direct bargaining without a neutral.
  • Interest-based negotiation and a clear BATNA produce better outcomes.
  • A settlement is a contract and may be registered in court under CPC Part V.
  • A bare agreement to negotiate is unenforceable (Walford v Miles), but defined ADR steps can bind.
  • Skipping a pre-arbitration step can defeat the arbitrator’s jurisdiction (Hodi v Jandu Plumbers).

Key Statutes and Cases on Negotiation and Settlement Agreements

Statutes

  • Law of Contract Act, Cap. 345Requirements of a valid settlement contract; free consent
  • Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33Part V settlement by negotiation may be registered in court
  • Arbitration Act, Cap. 15 R.E. 2023s. 35 objections to jurisdiction; s. 80 loss of right to object

Cases

  • M/S Hodi (Hotel Management) Co. Ltd v M/S Jandu Plumbers Ltd, Civil Appeal No. 396 of 2022, [2025] TZCA 138Pre-arbitration step not completed; arbitrator lacked jurisdiction
  • Walford v Miles [1992] 2 AC 128Bare agreement to negotiate is unenforceable
  • Cable & Wireless plc v IBM United Kingdom Ltd [2002] EWHC 2059 (Comm)Sufficiently certain ADR clause is enforceable

Test yourself

Negotiation and Settlement Agreements Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback

Take the quiz

Get the Full Alternative Dispute Resolution Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Test yourselfNegotiation and Settlement AgreementsTake the quiz