In short
Because customary, Islamic and statutory succession laws coexist in Tanzania Mainland, a court must first decide which law governs the estate. Courts use two related tests: the intention test (what law the deceased intended, expressly or impliedly, to govern the estate) and the mode of life test (how the deceased actually lived). Section 88 of the Probate and Administration of Estates Act, Cap. 352 sets presumptions: the estate of a member of a tribe is administered according to that tribe’s customary law unless the deceased professed Islam and intended Islamic law to apply, and the estate of a Muslim is administered according to Islamic law unless the deceased’s declarations, acts or manner of life show an intention that customary law should apply. In Re Innocent Mbilinyi [1969] HCD 283, the High Court applied the Indian Succession Act to a Christian whose mode of life had departed from Ngoni custom.
On this page 8 sections
Why is choice of law important?
- It decides who inherits and in what shares: for example, a widow may take a substantial share under the Indian Succession Act but little under customary law (GN 436 of 1963).
- It decides which court has jurisdiction: primary courts may administer estates only where the applicable law is customary or Islamic law; see Courts and Jurisdiction in Probate and Administration.
- Family members often argue for the law that favours them, which is why courts insist that the test focuses on the deceased, not the survivors.
What does section 88 of the PAEA provide?
- The estate of a member of a tribe is administered according to the law of that tribe, unless the deceased professed Islam and the court is satisfied, from the deceased’s declarations, acts or manner of life, that he intended the estate to be administered wholly or partly according to Islamic law.
- The estate of a Muslim (including a “Swahili”) is administered according to Islamic law unless the court is satisfied, from the deceased’s written or oral declarations or acts or manner of life, that he intended it to be administered wholly or partly according to customary law.
- An estate may follow the law applicable to Christians where the deceased professed Christianity and intended that law to apply.
- No person loses a right to inherit merely because he has renounced, or is excluded from, a religion, and creditors keep their rights against the estate.
High Court decisions often stress that the law of succession is for the deceased, not the survivors, which is why the mode of life test targets the deceased’s own life.
How do the intention and mode of life tests work?
- Intention: where the deceased expressly stated which law should govern, for example in a will or a declaration, the court gives effect to it.
- Mode of life: where there is no express statement, intention is inferred from how the deceased lived: religious practice, form of marriage (church, Islamic or customary), whether he paid bridewealth, took part in clan affairs, lived in a rural customary setting or an urban one, how he held his property and how he educated his children.
- Dominant mode: where the deceased lived a mixed or hybrid life, the court looks for the dominant mode of life, often at the end of life.
- Religion alone is not decisive: a Christian may still have lived a customary life, and courts have held that professing Christianity does not by itself remove a person from customary law.
What did Re Innocent Mbilinyi decide?
Innocent Mbilinyi, a Ngoni, died intestate. The Administrator-General sought directions on whether Ngoni customary law under GN 436 of 1963 or the law applicable to Christians, the Indian Succession Act, should govern the estate. The widow argued for the Indian Succession Act; the deceased’s father, brothers and sisters argued for customary law. Georges, C.J. examined how the deceased had actually lived and directed that the estate be administered under the Indian Succession Act, the law applicable to Christians, rather than Ngoni customary law. The case is the classic authority for the mode of life test.
How do courts apply the tests today?
- Primary and district courts must determine the applicable law before appointing an administrator or distributing an estate. Failure to determine the deceased’s mode of life has been treated by the High Court as a serious irregularity requiring the matter to start afresh.
- Evidence comes from family members, clan meetings, church or mosque records, marriage certificates and the deceased’s own declarations.
- Where a will exists, its form (customary, Islamic or statutory) may itself show the intended law; see Wills under Statutory Law and Wills under Customary and Islamic Law.
Exam focus: what do examiners test on choice of law?
- Why choice of law matters (shares and jurisdiction).
- Section 88 of the PAEA and its presumptions.
- The intention and mode of life tests, and the dominant mode in hybrid lives.
- Re Innocent Mbilinyi and its reasoning.
- The principle that the test concerns the deceased, not the survivors.
Practice question: the hybrid life
Question: Mzee Saning’o, a Chagga, married in church, worked for 30 years in Dar es Salaam, and lived in a house in Mikocheni with his wife and children. He also kept a family coffee farm in Moshi and attended clan meetings. He died intestate. His widow wants the Indian Succession Act to apply; his brothers want Chagga customary law. Advise.
- The court must decide the applicable law before distribution, focusing on the deceased’s intention and mode of life.
- Factors for statutory law: Christian marriage, long urban life, nuclear-family household. Factors for customary law: clan participation and the family farm.
- Following Re Innocent Mbilinyi, the court looks for the dominant mode of life; on these facts it may favour the Indian Succession Act, though the clan farm might be treated differently if it is clan land.
- If customary law applies, the primary court has jurisdiction; if statutory law applies, the estate goes to a district delegate or the High Court.
Key takeaways
- Choice of law decides both who inherits and which court has jurisdiction.
- Section 88 of the PAEA sets presumptions for tribal members, Muslims and Christians, rebuttable by evidence of intention and manner of life.
- Courts use the intention and mode of life tests, looking for the dominant mode where the life was mixed.
- Re Innocent Mbilinyi applied the Indian Succession Act to a Christian whose life had moved away from custom.
- The test focuses on the deceased, not the interests of survivors.
Key Statutes and Cases on Choice of Law in Succession: Mode of Life and Intention
Statutes
- Probate and Administration of Estates Act, Cap. 352s. 88 law applicable to estates of tribe members, Muslims and Christians
- Magistrates' Courts Act, Cap. 11Fifth Schedule, primary court jurisdiction depends on applicable law
Cases
- Re Innocent Mbilinyi [1969] HCD 283Mode of life test; Indian Succession Act applied
Test yourself
Choice of Law in Succession: Mode of Life and Intention Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback
