Private International Law notes · Topic 3 of 17

Domicile in Private International Law: Origin, Choice and Dependence

Domicile as the connecting factor for personal law: the Udny v Udny rules, domicile of origin, choice and dependence, revival, proof, the married woman's domicile in Tanzania after Gharib Abdallah Juma v Kay Mlinga, and domicile versus nationality.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 16 min read

In short

Domicile is a person’s permanent home in the eyes of the law: the country whose legal system is his or her personal law. It decides questions such as capacity to marry and succession to movable property. Everyone has exactly one domicile at any time. You get a domicile of origin at birth, can replace it with a domicile of choice by living in a country with the intention of staying there permanently, and some people (children, and under the old common law married women) have a domicile of dependence. Tanzania applies these English common law rules through section 2(3) of JALA.

On this page 11 sections
  1. What is domicile in private international law?
  2. What is a "country" of domicile?
  3. What are the general rules on domicile?
  4. What is a domicile of origin?
  5. How is a domicile of choice acquired?
  6. How is a domicile of choice lost, and what is revival?
  7. What is a domicile of dependence?
  8. How is domicile different from nationality and residence?
  9. Exam focus: what do examiners test on domicile?
  10. Practice question: Dr Mussa's estate
  11. Key takeaways

What is domicile in private international law?

Domicile is the connecting factor that links a person to a legal system for matters of personal law. Put simply, it is the country a person treats as his or her permanent home, in the legal sense. The law of that country (the lex domicilii) traditionally governs:

  • capacity to marry;
  • succession to movable property, whether by will or on intestacy;
  • many questions of status, such as legitimacy;
  • in many systems, the jurisdiction of courts in matrimonial matters.

Domicile is a legal concept, not a fact you can read from a passport. A person can be born in one country, hold the citizenship of a second and live in a third, yet be domiciled in the first. That is why domicile is one of the most examined topics in this subject. It follows on from Characterisation (Classification) in Private International Law: once an issue is characterised as one of personal law, domicile is usually the connecting factor.

What is a “country” of domicile?

You are domiciled in a territory that has its own system of law, not necessarily a whole state. Within federal or composite states each law district counts separately. In Tanzania this matters because Mainland Tanzania and Zanzibar keep separate laws in many fields, so for some purposes a person may be domiciled in Zanzibar rather than in Mainland Tanzania. The country of domicile need not be the country of birth or of nationality.

What are the general rules on domicile?

The general principles were laid down by the House of Lords in Udny v Udny (1869) LR 1 Sc & Div 441, especially by Lord Westbury. They are:

  1. No person can be without a domicile. The law gives everyone a domicile of origin at birth, and it revives whenever a domicile of choice is abandoned without a new one being acquired.
  2. No person can have more than one domicile at a time, at least for the same purpose. The aim is to link each person to one definite legal system.
  3. An existing domicile is presumed to continue. Whoever alleges a change must prove it.
  4. Domicile is decided by the law of the forum. A Tanzanian court applies its own (received English) concept of domicile, not the foreign country’s concept. In Re Annesley [1926] Ch 692 the English court held that the deceased was domiciled in France under English law, even though French law at the time did not regard her as domiciled there.

What is a domicile of origin?

A domicile of origin is the domicile the law gives every person at birth. It does not depend on where the child is born but on the domicile of the relevant parent at the time of birth:

  • a child born in wedlock takes the father’s domicile;
  • a child born outside wedlock, or after the father’s death, takes the mother’s domicile;
  • a foundling takes the domicile of the place where it is found.

The domicile of origin is very tenacious. In Udny v Udny Lord Westbury explained that because it is created by law and not by the person’s own act, it cannot be entirely extinguished by the person’s act; it is only placed in abeyance while a domicile of choice exists.

The leading illustration is Winans v Attorney-General [1904] AC 287. William Winans was born in the United States with an American domicile of origin. He lived in England for about the last 37 years of his life, but he disliked England, kept plans for property in Baltimore, and was absorbed in schemes to strengthen American naval power. The House of Lords held that he died domiciled in the United States: long residence alone did not show the intention needed to displace his domicile of origin.

How is a domicile of choice acquired?

An adult of full capacity acquires a domicile of choice by combining two things:

  1. Residence (factum): physical presence in the country as an inhabitant.
  2. Intention (animus): an intention to reside there permanently or indefinitely.

Both must exist at the same time. Neither is enough alone.

Residence

Length of residence is evidence, not a requirement. Very long residence may still fail to produce a domicile of choice if the intention is missing, as in Winans, and in Ramsay v Liverpool Royal Infirmary [1930] AC 588, where a man born in Glasgow lived in Liverpool for about 36 years until his death but was held to have kept his Scottish domicile of origin. Conversely, very short residence can be enough if the intention is clear. Residence that is unlawful under immigration law may still count: the House of Lords so held in Mark v Mark [2005] UKHL 42.

Intention

The intention must be to remain permanently or indefinitely. An intention to stay only for a limited purpose or until a definite event is not enough:

  • Jopp v Wood (1865) 4 De G J & S 616: a man who lived and worked in India for about 25 years, intending to return home eventually, did not acquire an Indian domicile.
  • IRC v Bullock [1976] 1 WLR 1178: a Canadian who lived in England for over 40 years, but intended to return to Canada if his wife died first, kept his Canadian domicile. A realistic contingency of return defeats the required intention.
  • Cramer v Cramer [1987] 1 FLR 116: a woman with a French domicile of origin who came to England intending to stay only if her relationship with a married man led to marriage did not acquire an English domicile; her intention was conditional.

Courts examine the whole life of the person: where the family lives, property owned, business interests, statements of intention, membership of clubs and churches, voting, and plans for burial. Declarations are weighed against conduct, and conduct usually prevails.

The burden and standard of proof

The person alleging a change of domicile carries the burden. The standard is the civil balance of probabilities, but because the domicile of origin is so tenacious, courts require clear evidence before holding it displaced (Winans; Re Fuld’s Estate (No 3) [1968] P 675).

How is a domicile of choice lost, and what is revival?

A domicile of choice is lost by ceasing to reside in the country and ceasing to intend to reside there permanently. If the person does not immediately acquire a new domicile of choice, the domicile of origin revives automatically. In Udny v Udny, Colonel Udny had a Scottish domicile of origin and acquired a domicile of choice in England. He later left England for France to escape his creditors, with no intention of returning. His English domicile of choice was abandoned, and his Scottish domicile of origin revived. As a result his son, born to parents who later married, was legitimated under Scots law.

What is a domicile of dependence?

A domicile of dependence is attached by law to people treated as unable to choose their own domicile. Their domicile follows that of the person they depend on.

  • Children: a child’s domicile follows the domicile of the father (or the mother, where the child is born outside wedlock or the parents are separated and the child lives with her) until the child can acquire an independent domicile.
  • Persons lacking mental capacity: generally keep the domicile they had when they lost capacity, or follow a parent’s domicile if they were children.
  • Married women at common law: under the common law a married woman’s domicile was the same as her husband’s for as long as the marriage lasted, even if they lived apart (Lord Advocate v Jaffrey [1921] 1 AC 146).

Does the married woman’s dependent domicile still apply in Tanzania?

This is a favourite exam question. In England the rule was abolished by section 1 of the Domicile and Matrimonial Proceedings Act 1973, which gives a married woman an independent domicile. That Act was passed long after the 22 July 1920 reception date in section 2(3) of JALA, so it does not apply in Tanzania. The common law rule was received.

The Court of Appeal applied the old rule in Gharib Abdallah Juma v Kay Mlinga, Civil Appeal No. 10 of 2001, [2002] TZCA 10; [2004] T.L.R. 74. The respondent, a Mainland Tanzanian married to a Zanzibari living in Denmark, claimed a share of houses in Zanzibar. Only a Zanzibari may own land in Zanzibar. The Court held that her residence in Zanzibar did not make her a Zanzibari and that her domicile was presumed to follow her husband’s, which was in Denmark. She therefore received the money value of her share instead of the land itself.

You should also argue the other side. Article 13 of the Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania guarantees equality before the law and prohibits discrimination, including on the basis of sex. A strong argument exists that a rule giving every wife her husband’s domicile is inconsistent with that guarantee and should not be followed today, and that section 2(3) itself only receives English law so far as local circumstances permit. A good answer states the received rule, cites Gharib, and then evaluates it against Article 13.

How is domicile different from nationality and residence?

Domicile Nationality Residence
Meaning Legal permanent home; links a person to a legal system Political membership of a state Where a person actually lives
Decided by The law of the forum The law of the state concerned (in Tanzania, the Tanzania Citizenship Act, Cap. 357) The facts
How many Always exactly one None, one or several None, one or several
Can it be lost without gaining another? No (the domicile of origin revives) Yes Yes

Nationality and habitual residence as connecting factors are covered in Nationality and Habitual Residence as Connecting Factors.

Exam focus: what do examiners test on domicile?

  • State the four general rules from Udny v Udny and Re Annesley.
  • Explain the two elements of a domicile of choice and use Winans, Ramsay, IRC v Bullock and Cramer v Cramer on intention.
  • Explain revival of the domicile of origin using the facts of Udny.
  • Discuss the married woman’s dependent domicile in Tanzania: received common law, applied in Gharib, the English 1973 Act not received, and the Article 13 argument.
  • Distinguish domicile from nationality and residence.

Practice question: Dr Mussa’s estate

Question: Dr Mussa was born in Tanga to a father domiciled in Tanzania. At 30 he moved to the United Kingdom, worked there for 28 years, bought a house and often said he would “retire to Tanga when the children finish school”. He died in London with his children still at university, leaving bank accounts in Tanzania. Where was he domiciled?

  1. Issue: did he acquire a domicile of choice in England, displacing his Tanzanian domicile of origin?
  2. Rule: a domicile of choice needs residence plus an intention to remain permanently or indefinitely; the domicile of origin is tenacious and clear proof is needed (Udny, Winans).
  3. Application: he clearly resided in England, but his repeated statements of a definite plan to return when a foreseeable event happened resemble IRC v Bullock and Jopp v Wood. Long residence and a house are not enough without the intention (Ramsay).
  4. Conclusion: he probably died domiciled in Tanzania, so Tanzanian law, as the law of his domicile, governs succession to his movables.

Key takeaways

  • Domicile links a person to a legal system for capacity, succession to movables and status.
  • Everyone has one domicile; existing domicile is presumed to continue; domicile is decided by the lex fori.
  • Domicile of origin is fixed at birth by the relevant parent’s domicile and revives when a domicile of choice is abandoned (Udny v Udny).
  • A domicile of choice requires residence plus intention to remain permanently or indefinitely; contingent or limited intentions fail (Winans, Ramsay, IRC v Bullock, Cramer v Cramer).
  • At common law a wife’s domicile follows her husband’s; the Court of Appeal applied this in Gharib Abdallah Juma v Kay Mlinga, but the rule is open to challenge under Article 13 of the Constitution.

Key Statutes and Cases on Domicile in Private International Law: Origin, Choice and Dependence

Statutes

  • Judicature and Application of Laws Act, Cap. 358 R.E. 2019s. 2(3) reception of common law rules on domicile
  • Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania, 1977Art. 13 (equality before the law)
  • Tanzania Citizenship Act, Cap. 357Nationality, distinguished from domicile

Cases

  • Udny v Udny (1869) LR 1 Sc & Div 441General rules; tenacity and revival of the domicile of origin
  • Winans v Attorney-General [1904] AC 287Long residence without intention does not create a domicile of choice
  • Ramsay v Liverpool Royal Infirmary [1930] AC 58836 years in Liverpool; Scottish domicile of origin retained
  • IRC v Bullock [1976] 1 WLR 1178Realistic contingency of return defeats intention
  • Re Annesley [1926] Ch 692Domicile is decided by the law of the forum
  • Lord Advocate v Jaffrey [1921] 1 AC 146Married woman's dependent domicile at common law
  • Gharib Abdallah Juma v Kay Mlinga, Civil Appeal No. 10 of 2001, [2002] TZCA 10; [2004] T.L.R. 74Wife's domicile presumed to follow her husband's

Test yourself

Domicile in Private International Law: Origin, Choice and Dependence Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback

Take the quiz

Get the Full Private International Law Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Test yourselfDomicile in Private International Law: Origin, Choice and DependenceTake the quiz