Let me start with a sentence you must remember and probably will write in many exam answers: the right of appeal is a creature of statute. Unlike the right to be heard, which is a fundamental constitutional right, the right of appeal exists only where a statute says it does. If no statute creates the right, there is no right.
This matters in practice because your client cannot demand to appeal just because he is unhappy with a decision. You must check whether the statute that governs the kind of decision gives a right of appeal, what conditions are attached (time limits, leave, certificates on a point of law), and to which higher court the appeal goes.
The appellate structure in Tanzania is layered. First appeals from subordinate courts go to the High Court, governed by the CPC. Appeals from the High Court go to the Court of Appeal of Tanzania, governed by the Appellate Jurisdiction Act, Cap. 141 R.E. 2023, and the Tanzania Court of Appeal Rules, 2009 (GN No. 368 of 2009). The Court of Appeal is our apex court in civil matters.
The procedural rules for appeals to the Court of Appeal are notoriously strict, and a great many appeals have been struck out for failure to comply. Get the steps right.
The Right to Sue versus the Right to Appeal
Under section 9 of the CPC, the courts may try all suits of a civil nature unless barred, so a person with a civil grievance can sue in a proper court. But the right to appeal is separate and is not automatic. The right to appeal must be expressly conferred by law.
Not every judgment, decree, or order is appealable. The statute that creates the right of appeal also sets the conditions — what kinds of decisions can be appealed, who can appeal, by when, in what form, to which court.
The Structure of Appellate Provisions in the CPC
The CPC’s main appellate provisions are:
Sections 80 to 83 — appeals from original decrees (first appeals).
Sections 84 to 85 — appeals from orders (a narrower right than the right to appeal from decrees; only specific orders are appealable).
Section 86 — the powers of the appellate court.
Second appeals — the CPC does not provide a second appeal to the High Court. An appeal from the High Court’s decision on a first appeal goes to the Court of Appeal under the Appellate Jurisdiction Act, Cap. 141 R.E. 2023.
Order XXXIX — the form, grounds, and procedure for appeals from original decrees.
Order XL — the form, procedure, and rules for appeals from orders.
The structural picture, then, is:
A decree gives an automatic right of first appeal to the High Court (subject to statutory conditions).
An order gives a right of appeal only where the law specifically allows it.
A first appellate decision can be the subject of a second appeal, generally on a point of law only.
Appeals to the Court of Appeal proceed under a separate statute, the Appellate Jurisdiction Act.
First Appeals — Decrees Re-Examined on Fact and Law
A first appeal is the appeal from a court of first instance to the first appellate court. The first appellate court is entitled to re-examine both findings of fact and findings of law. It can re-evaluate the evidence on the record, although it will usually defer to the trial court on questions of witness credibility (because the trial court saw the witnesses; the appellate court has only the transcript).
A first appeal from a District Court or Resident Magistrate’s Court goes to the High Court. The appeal is by way of a memorandum of appeal setting out the grounds of appeal, accompanied by a copy of the decree and the judgment appealed against.
The first appeal must be filed within the time fixed by law (90 days from the date of the decree under the Law of Limitation Act, Cap. 89 R.E. 2023; the time taken to obtain copies is excluded where they were requested in writing). If filed out of time, an application for extension of time must be made, supported by affidavit, on sufficient cause.
Second Appeals — Points of Law Only
A second appeal is the appeal from the first appellate court to the next court above (commonly the High Court to the Court of Appeal). At this level, the appellate court will generally not disturb concurrent findings of fact. The appeal is confined to points of law.
The rationale is that findings of fact, having been examined by both the trial court and the first appellate court, are unlikely to be wrong, and re-examining them on a second appeal would be wasteful. The exception is where the findings are clearly perverse or contrary to the evidence.
Since 1 December 2023, leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal is no longer generally required, but some second appeals still need a certificate on a point of law, depending on the statute, and interlocutory orders remain unappealable.
Appeals to the Court of Appeal of Tanzania
The Court of Appeal of Tanzania is the apex court in civil matters. Appeals to it are governed by:
The Appellate Jurisdiction Act, Cap. 141 R.E. 2023.
The Tanzania Court of Appeal Rules, 2009 (GN No. 368 of 2009).
Key Statutes and Cases on Appeals
Statutes
- Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2023ss. 80 to 83 appeals from decrees; ss. 84 and 85 appeals from orders; s. 86 powers on appeal; Orders XXXIX and XL
- Law of Limitation Act, Cap. 89 R.E. 202390 days for appeals under the Code
- Appellate Jurisdiction Act, Cap. 141 R.E. 2023s. 5 appeals to the Court of Appeal; leave abolished from 1 December 2023 (Act No. 11 of 2023)
- Tanzania Court of Appeal Rules, 2009r. 83 notice of appeal; r. 90 letter and 60 days; r. 96 record of appeal
Cases
- Lyamuya Construction Co. Ltd v Board of Registered Trustees of Young Women's Christian Association of Tanzania, Civil Application No. 2 of 2010 (CAT)Extension of time: account for every day of delay
Test yourself
Appeals Practice Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
