On this page 6 sections
- What is a reply to a petition of appeal?
- Do you have to file a reply to a petition of appeal?
- How do you draft a reply to a petition of appeal?
- How do you answer grounds of appeal effectively?
- What is the difference between a petition of appeal and a memorandum of appeal?
- Sample Reply to the Petition of Appeal Format
What is a reply to a petition of appeal?
A reply to a petition of appeal is the respondent’s written answer to each ground in the appellant’s petition. It is used in appeals that go by petition, mainly appeals in proceedings that started in a primary court. These are governed by sections 20 and 25 of the Magistrates’ Courts Act, Cap. 11 R.E. 2023 and the Civil Procedure (Appeals in Proceedings Originating in Primary Courts) Rules, GN No. 312 of 1964. The reply puts the respondent’s position on record and asks the court to dismiss the appeal with costs.
Do you have to file a reply to a petition of appeal?
The appeal will be heard whether or not you reply, but a reply is the best way to put your answer before the court in advance and to show which grounds are really in dispute. Where the court directs a reply or written submissions, follow its directions and dates exactly. If you also want part of the lower court’s decision changed, a reply is not enough: you must lodge your own appeal within the time allowed.
How do you draft a reply to a petition of appeal?
- Copy the headingUse the same court, appeal number and “Arising from” line as the petition, so the reply goes into the right file.
- Parties and titleKeep the appellant and respondent as named in the petition, then the title “Reply to Petition of Appeal”.
- Answer each ground in orderTake the grounds one by one. State whether you dispute each ground and give a short reason based on the record: the evidence, an exhibit or a finding of the court below.
- Stay within the recordAn appeal is decided on the record of the lower courts. Do not introduce new facts or evidence in the reply.
- PrayerAsk that the appeal be dismissed in its entirety with costs, or state any narrower position you take.
- Sign, file and serveDate and sign, leave space for the registry endorsement, add “Drawn and filed by” and serve a copy on the appellant.
How do you answer grounds of appeal effectively?
- Group grounds that make the same complaint and answer them together, saying so.
- Where a ground complains about a minor error, say why it caused no miscarriage of justice (as ground 1 in the sample does).
- Where both courts below made the same finding of fact, point that out: a second appellate court is slow to disturb concurrent findings of fact.
- Where a ground raises a new point that was never argued below, say so.
- Keep it short. Your detailed arguments go in the submissions or at the hearing.
What is the difference between a petition of appeal and a memorandum of appeal?
A petition of appeal is used for appeals in matters that began in a primary court, for criminal appeals to the High Court, and for appeals from the District Land and Housing Tribunal. A memorandum of appeal under Order XXXIX of the Civil Procedure Code is used for civil appeals from a district or resident magistrate’s court exercising original jurisdiction. Answer the document you were served with, in the matching format.
Sample Reply to the Petition of Appeal Format
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TANZANIA
AT TANGA
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 3 OF 20…
(Arising from Civil Appeal No. 7 of 20… of Korogwe District Court and Original Civil Case No. 578 of 20…. of Manundu Primary Court)
DENGU TAMU…………….……………………………………..…………………. APPELLANT
Versus
PAPAI BICHI…………………………………..…………………………………….. RESPONDENT
REPLY TO PETITION OF APPEAL
The above-named Respondent reply to the Applellant’s petition of appeal as follows
-
The first ground of appeal is disputed as being trivial and inconsequential to the merits of the case and the apparent disparity of dates did not occasion any miscarriage of justice.
-
That the Respondent disputes the second ground of appeal and states that on the preponderance of the evidence adduced the Appellant’s defense of bona fide claim of right is unfounded.
-
That in view of the High Court decision in Land Appeal No. 62 of 20.., Exhibit P2, the Appellant’s assertion of long possession in the third ground of appeal is devoid of merit.
-
That the Respondent disputes the fourth ground of Appeal as being unfounded.
-
That the respondent disputes the fifth ground of Appeal.
THEREFORE the Respondent prays that the Appeal be dismissed in its entirety with costs.
Dated at Tanga this …………………..……… day of ……………………..…….………………. 20….
……………………………
RESPONDENT
Presented for filing this ………..……… day of ………………………………………..………….. 20..
REGISTRY OFFICER
Drawn & Filed by:
Papai Bichi
(The Respondent)
To be served upon:
The Appellant
Download this template
- PDF ready to printPro
- Word fully editableElite
Each copy carries your name for personal use.
Pakua template hii kwa PDF au Word.
Learn the law behind it
