Legal Methods notes · Topic 5 of 9

Doctrine of Stare Decisis

Explanation of the doctrine of stare decisis, judicial precedent, court hierarchy, and its application in England, East Africa, and Tanzania.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 9 min read
On this page 28 sections
  1. Introduction to the Doctrine of Stare Decisis
  2. Meaning of Stare Decisis
  3. Purpose and Importance of Stare Decisis
  4. Judicial Precedent
  5. Key Components of a Judicial Decision
  6. Types of Precedent
  7. Doctrine of Precedent and Court Hierarchy
  8. Doctrine of Stare Decisis in England
  9. Stare Decisis Before 1966 (The Old Rule)
  10. Exceptions to the Old Rule
  11. The 1966 Practice Statement (The New Rule)
  12. Application of Precedent in the Court of Appeal (England)
  13. Additional Exceptions in Criminal Cases
  14. Doctrine of Precedent in East Africa
  15. Role of the Privy Council
  16. Abolition of Appeals to the Privy Council
  17. Conflicting Views on Privy Council Decisions
  18. English Decisions and Their Influence in East Africa
  19. Reception of English Law in Tanganyika
  20. Kiriri Cotton Co Ltd v Dewani [1958] EA 239
  21. Statutes in Pari Materia
  22. The Court of Appeal of Tanzania
  23. Jurisdiction of the Court of Appeal
  24. Doctrine of Precedent in Tanzania
  25. Practical Illustration of Stare Decisis
  26. Advantages of the Doctrine of Stare Decisis
  27. Disadvantages of Strict Precedent
  28. Key Exam Takeaways

Introduction to the Doctrine of Stare Decisis

The doctrine of stare decisis is one of the most important principles in the common law legal system, including the legal system of Tanzania.

The phrase stare decisis is a Latin expression which means “to stand by decided cases” or “let the decision stand.”

The doctrine requires that:

  • Courts must follow previous judicial decisions (precedents) when deciding cases with similar facts and legal issues.

  • Lower courts must follow the decisions of higher courts in the judicial hierarchy.

  • Courts should maintain consistency and certainty in the law.

In simple terms, the doctrine ensures that similar cases are decided in the same way, unless there is a strong reason to change the law.


Meaning of Stare Decisis

Definition

Stare decisis is the legal principle that courts must follow previously decided cases when the same legal issue arises again.

This means:

  • If a higher court has already decided a legal issue,

  • Lower courts must apply that same rule in future similar cases.

Thus, judges do not create law entirely from scratch. Instead, they rely on earlier judicial decisions.


Purpose and Importance of Stare Decisis

The doctrine serves several important functions in the legal system.

1. Certainty in the Law

Stare decisis ensures that the law is predictable.

People can plan their activities knowing that courts will apply established legal rules.

2. Consistency and Equality

It ensures that similar cases are treated in the same way, promoting fairness and equality before the law.

3. Efficiency in the Courts

Judges can rely on existing legal principles instead of re-examining the law every time a case arises.

4. Development of the Law

Judicial decisions gradually develop and refine legal principles over time.


Judicial Precedent

Meaning of Precedent

A precedent is a previous judicial decision that serves as a guide or authority for deciding later cases involving similar facts or legal issues.

When a court decides a case:

  • The legal reasoning used by the judge may become a precedent.

  • Later courts may rely on that reasoning when deciding new cases.


Key Components of a Judicial Decision

Understanding precedent requires distinguishing two important parts of a judgment.

Ratio Decidendi

The ratio decidendi means “the reason for the decision.”

It refers to:

  • The legal principle or rule of law upon which the court based its decision.

Only the ratio decidendi is binding as precedent.

Obiter Dicta

Obiter dicta means “things said by the way.”

These are:

  • Observations or comments made by judges that are not necessary for the final decision.

Obiter dicta are not binding, but they may have persuasive authority.


Types of Precedent

Binding Precedent

A binding precedent is a previous decision that must be followed by a court.

This usually happens when:

  • The decision comes from a higher court in the judicial hierarchy.

Example:

  • Decisions of the Court of Appeal of Tanzania are binding on:

    • The High Court

    • Subordinate courts

Persuasive Precedent

A persuasive precedent is a decision that a court may consider but is not required to follow.

Examples include:

  • Decisions of courts in other jurisdictions

  • Obiter dicta

  • Decisions of courts of equal status


Doctrine of Precedent and Court Hierarchy

The doctrine of precedent operates based on the hierarchy of courts.

There are two major forms of precedent obligation.

Vertical Precedent

This occurs when lower courts must follow decisions of higher courts.

Example:

  • High Court must follow decisions of the Court of Appeal.

Horizontal Precedent

This occurs when courts follow their own previous decisions.

However, courts may sometimes depart from their previous decisions under certain circumstances.


Doctrine of Stare Decisis in England

The doctrine of precedent developed primarily in England, the origin of the common law system.

Test yourself

Doctrine of Stare Decisis and Judicial Precedent Quiz Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free

Take the quiz

Get the Full Legal Methods Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Keep reading this topicFrom TSh 5,000 a weekJoin Now