On this page 21 sections
- Introduction to the Topic
- Meaning of Attempt
- Elements of Attempt
- Preparation vs Attempt
- Case Law on Attempt
- Attempt in Theft Cases
- Attempted Murder
- Attempted Rape
- Impossibility in Attempt
- Why Attempt is Punished
- Specific Offences of Attempt
- Meaning of Conspiracy
- Elements of Conspiracy
- Key Principle
- Features of Conspiracy
- Case Law
- Special Rules in Conspiracy
- Practical Example
- Important Distinctions
- Exam Approach
- Key Takeaways
Introduction to the Topic
In criminal law, some offences are punished even before they are completed. These are called inchoate offences.
The two main inchoate offences are:
-
Attempt
-
Conspiracy
These offences are important because they allow the law to punish individuals who show a clear intention to commit crimes—even if the crime is not fully completed.
The main statutory provisions include:
-
Section 380 Penal Code – Attempt
-
Section 382 Penal Code – Punishment for attempt
-
Section 386 Penal Code – Conspiracy
Meaning of Attempt
Definition
An attempt is:
👉 An act done with intent to commit a crime, forming part of a series of acts which would result in the commission of that crime if not interrupted.
Key Idea
-
The law does not punish mere intention
-
There must be some action beyond preparation
Elements of Attempt
To prove attempt, the prosecution must establish:
Mens Rea (Guilty Mind)
-
The accused must have intended to commit the specific offence
-
Mere recklessness is not enough
Actus Reus (Guilty Act)
-
There must be an overt act
-
The act must go beyond preparation
-
The act must be proximate to the commission of the offence
Preparation vs Attempt
Preparation
-
Acts done to get ready for committing a crime
-
Not punishable
Example:
-
Buying poison to kill someone
Attempt
-
Acts that directly move towards committing the offence
-
Punishable
Example:
-
Putting poison into someone’s drink
Key Test
👉 Has the accused begun execution of the crime?
Case Law on Attempt
R v Robinson [1915] 2 KB 342
The accused staged a fake burglary to claim insurance but had not yet contacted the insurer.
Held: this was only preparation, not attempt.
Significance:
There must be a step directly connected to the offence.
Attempt in Theft Cases
Key Principle
There must be asportation (movement of property).
Ambokile Mwamalongo v Republic (1967) H.C.D. No. 275
The accused partially removed a purse from the victim’s pocket.
Held: sufficient movement → attempt proved.
Kombo Abdaraman v Republic [1980] T.L.R. 90
The accused tried to put his hand into the victim’s pocket but failed.
Held: attempt established because execution had begun.
Attempted Murder
Legal Requirement
Under section 211 Penal Code, the prosecution must prove:
👉 Intention to kill, not merely intention to cause harm
Case Law
R v Christopher Ngambilo (1967) H.C.D. No. 388
The accused shot the victim in the knee.
Held: no attempted murder—no proof of intent to kill.
R v Rukondo Kamaro (1968) H.C.D. No. 48
Accused shot arrows from a distance.
Held: only grievous harm, not attempted murder.
Exam Tip
Always distinguish:
-
Murder → intention to kill OR cause grievous harm
-
Attempted murder → intention to kill only
Attempted Rape
Legal Requirement
Under section 132 Penal Code, the prosecution must prove:
-
intention to have sexual intercourse
-
intention to do so despite resistance
Case Law
Mulira v Republic (1953) 20 E.A.C.A. 223
The accused undressed and assaulted the victim but fled when she screamed.
Held: not attempted rape → only assault with intent
Omar v Republic (1971) H.C.D. No. 362
The accused tore clothes but did not proceed further.
Held: indecent assault, not attempted rape
Modern Approach
R v Andrew Avarity (1973) L.R.T No. 92
The court moved away from strict technical rules.
Held:
-
Focus on intention
-
Look at overt acts
-
Do not over-emphasize “proximity”
Key Principle
If:
-
intention is clear, and
-
overt acts are proven
👉 attempt is established
Impossibility in Attempt
Rule
Under section 380 Penal Code:
👉 Impossibility is NOT a defence
Types of Impossibility
Factual Impossibility
-
Crime cannot be completed due to unknown facts
Example:
-
Trying to steal from an empty pocket
👉 Still liable
Legal Impossibility
-
The act is not actually a crime
👉 No liability
Case Law
Edward Michael v Republic (1948) 1 T.L.R. 308
The accused tried to sell fake diamonds believing they were real.
Held: guilty of attempt
Reason: intention + overt act = liability
Key Principle
👉 The court looks at what the accused believed he was doing
Why Attempt is Punished
The law punishes attempts because:
-
The accused shows dangerous intention
-
He is willing to break the law
-
Society must be protected early
Specific Offences of Attempt
Examples under the Penal Code:
-
Section 211 – Attempted murder
-
Section 132 – Attempted rape
-
Section 150 – Attempted abortion
-
Section 287 – Attempted robbery
-
Section 320 – Attempted arson
-
Section 382 – General punishment
Meaning of Conspiracy
Definition
A conspiracy is:
👉 An agreement between two or more persons to:
-
commit an unlawful act, OR
-
commit a lawful act by unlawful means
Elements of Conspiracy
Agreement
-
The core element
-
Must be between two or more persons
Unlawful Objective
-
The agreement must aim at something illegal
Intention
-
Each conspirator must intend to carry out the plan
Key Principle
👉 The crime is complete once there is agreement
No further act is required.
Features of Conspiracy
-
No need for direct communication
-
Members may join at different times
-
Each need not know full details
-
Even small participation is sufficient
Case Law
R v Karia (1949) 16 E.A.C.A. 116
The accused conspired to export diamonds illegally.
Held: conspiracy can be inferred from conduct.
Ogodia & Erima v Uganda [1967] E.A. 137
Conspiracy to set up a roadblock.
Held: agreement can be inferred even without direct proof.
Special Rules in Conspiracy
One person cannot conspire alone
At least two persons are required.
If one conspirator is acquitted
-
Others may also be acquitted
-
Unless conspiracy with unknown persons is proved
Exception
A person can be convicted:
-
even if others are unknown, dead, or absent
Practical Example
If A and B agree to rob a bank:
-
They are guilty of conspiracy immediately
-
Even if the robbery never happens
Important Distinctions
Attempt vs Conspiracy
|
Attempt |
Conspiracy |
|---|---|
|
Focus on action |
Focus on agreement |
|
Requires overt act |
No act required |
|
Individual liability |
Joint liability |
Preparation vs Attempt
|
Preparation |
Attempt |
|---|---|
|
Not punishable |
Punishable |
|
Remote acts |
Proximate acts |
Exam Approach
For Attempt Questions
-
Identify intention
-
Identify overt act
-
Distinguish preparation vs execution
-
Apply section 380
For Conspiracy Questions
-
Identify agreement
-
Identify participants
-
Identify unlawful purpose
-
Apply section 386
Key Takeaways
-
Attempt requires intention + overt act
-
Mere preparation is not enough
-
Impossibility is not a defence
-
Attempted murder requires intent to kill
-
Conspiracy is complete upon agreement
-
Even minimal participation can lead to liability
-
Courts focus on intention and conduct
Test yourself
Attempts and Conspiracy Practice Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback
