On this page 8 sections
Introduction to Contracts of Indemnity and Guarantee
Contracts of indemnity and contracts of guarantee are very important in commercial and financial transactions, particularly in banking and lending practices.
In Tanzania, banks frequently require guarantors before granting loans. This is a practical example of how contracts of guarantee operate in everyday commerce.
Both contracts are governed by the Law of Contract Act, Cap. 345 (Revised Edition 2023).
Although indemnity and guarantee appear similar because both deal with protection against financial loss, they are legally different. Understanding the distinction between them is very important for law examinations and legal practice.
These notes explain:
-
The meaning and definition of indemnity and guarantee
-
Key legal principles governing them
-
Rights and liabilities of parties
-
Important statutory provisions
-
Leading judicial interpretations
Contract of Indemnity
Meaning and Statutory Definition
A contract of indemnity is defined under Section 124 of the Law of Contract Act, Cap. 345 (R.E. 2023).
According to the Act:
A contract of indemnity is a contract by which one party promises to save the other from loss caused to him by the conduct of the promisor himself, or by the conduct of any other person.
The person who promises to compensate for the loss is called the indemnifier.
The person whose loss is protected is called the indemnified or indemnity holder.
Key Feature of an Indemnity Contract
The most important feature is that:
The indemnifier assumes responsibility for the loss.
This means the indemnifier promises that if loss occurs, he will compensate the indemnified party.
The liability of the indemnifier is primary and independent.
Illustration of a Contract of Indemnity
Suppose a shipping company signs a contract with a port authority stating that the company will compensate the authority for any damage caused by its ships while using the port.
If a ship damages port infrastructure, the shipping company must pay for the loss.
In this situation:
-
Shipping company → Indemnifier
-
Port authority → Indemnified party
The indemnifier bears the financial risk.
Judicial Interpretation of Indemnity
A well-known common law authority explaining indemnity obligations is:
Adamson v Jarvis (1827) 4 Bing 66
In this case:
An auctioneer sold cattle on behalf of a person who claimed to be the owner. Later it turned out that the cattle actually belonged to someone else. The real owner sued the auctioneer.
The court held that the person who instructed the auctioneer must indemnify the auctioneer for the loss suffered.
Legal principle established:
Where one person acts on the instructions of another, the person giving instructions must indemnify the other against losses arising from those instructions.
This principle strongly influences indemnity law in common law jurisdictions, including Tanzania.
Rights of the Indemnified Party
The rights of the indemnified party are provided under Section 125 of the Law of Contract Act, Cap. 345 (R.E. 2023).
When the indemnified party faces liability relating to the indemnified matter, they may recover the following from the indemnifier.
Recovery of Damages
The indemnified party may recover:
All damages paid in a suit relating to the matter covered by the indemnity.
This applies where the indemnified person was compelled to pay damages because of the event against which protection was promised.
Recovery of Legal Costs
The indemnified party may also recover:
All legal costs incurred in defending the suit, provided the defence was reasonable and not contrary to the indemnifier’s instructions.
Recovery of Compromise Payments
The indemnified party may recover:
Any amount paid in a reasonable settlement or compromise, provided:
-
The settlement was prudent, and
-
It was not against the indemnifier’s instructions.
Practical Illustration
Suppose a contractor indemnifies a property owner against damage caused during construction.
If a third party sues the owner and the owner pays:
-
damages of TZS 10,000,000
-
legal fees of TZS 2,000,000
The owner may recover the entire TZS 12,000,000 from the contractor.
Contract of Guarantee
Meaning and Statutory Definition
A contract of guarantee is defined under Section 126 of the Law of Contract Act, Cap. 345 (R.E. 2023).
According to the Act:
A contract of guarantee is a contract to perform the promise or discharge the liability of a third person in case of his default.
This means a person promises that if another person fails to fulfil an obligation, the guarantor will fulfil it instead.
Parties in a Contract of Guarantee
A guarantee always involves three parties.
Principal Debtor
The person who has the primary obligation to perform or repay the debt.
Creditor
The person to whom the debt or obligation is owed.
Surety (Guarantor)
The person who promises to perform the obligation if the principal debtor fails to do so.
Practical Example (Common in Banking)
Grace applies for a loan from CRDB Bank Plc.
The bank requires a guarantor before approving the loan.
Grace’s father, Mr. Mwamba, agrees to guarantee the loan.
In this situation:
-
Grace → Principal debtor
-
CRDB Bank → Creditor
-
Mr. Mwamba → Surety (guarantor)
If Grace fails to repay the loan, the bank may demand payment from Mr. Mwamba.
Important Legal Principle
The liability of the surety is secondary.
This means:
The surety becomes liable only when the principal debtor defaults.
This principle was clearly expressed in:
Birkmyr v Darnell (1704) 1 Salk 27
The court explained that a guarantee involves a promise to answer for the debt or default of another person.
This case is often cited to explain the nature of guarantee obligations.
Distinction Between Indemnity and Guarantee
Although both contracts protect against financial loss, they are legally different.
Number of Parties
Indemnity involves two parties:
-
Indemnifier
-
Indemnified
Guarantee involves three parties:
-
Creditor
-
Principal debtor
-
Surety
Nature of Liability
In an indemnity, the indemnifier has primary liability.
In a guarantee, the surety has secondary liability.
Nature of Obligation
In indemnity:
The obligation is original and independent.
In guarantee:
The obligation is collateral to the debt of the principal debtor.
Existence of Principal Debtor
In indemnity:
There may not necessarily be a principal debtor.
In guarantee:
A principal debtor must exist.
Simple Memory Tip for Exams
You can remember the difference using these phrases:
Indemnity:
“I will compensate you for the loss.”
Guarantee:
“If he fails to pay, I will pay.”
Rights of a Surety
The law recognizes that sureties often act out of trust or friendship, especially in family or banking contexts. Therefore, the law gives them several protections.
Important rights of a surety are provided under Sections 140, 145 and 146 of the Law of Contract Act (R.E. 2023).
Right of Subrogation — Section 140
After paying the debt of the principal debtor, the surety is entitled to step into the shoes of the creditor.
This means the surety may use all the rights that the creditor previously had against the principal debtor.
For example, the surety may:
-
sue the principal debtor
-
enforce securities held by the creditor
This principle ensures the surety can recover the money paid.
Right to Indemnity — Section 145
Under Section 145, the law provides that:
The principal debtor must indemnify the surety for all sums that the surety properly paid under the guarantee.
In other words:
If the surety pays the creditor, the principal debtor must reimburse the surety.
Illustration
If Mr. Mwamba pays TZS 5,000,000 to the bank after Grace defaults, he can legally demand the same amount from Grace.
Right of Contribution Between Co-Sureties — Section 146
Where there are multiple sureties, the law requires them to share liability equally unless the contract provides otherwise.
For example:
If two guarantors guarantee a loan of TZS 10,000,000 and one guarantor pays the entire amount, that guarantor may recover TZS 5,000,000 from the other guarantor.
This right is called the right of contribution.
Discharge of a Surety
A surety may be released from liability in several circumstances.
These are mainly provided under Sections 133–139 of the Law of Contract Act, Cap. 345 (R.E. 2023).
Understanding these provisions is very important for contract law examinations.
Variation of the Contract Without Surety’s Consent — Section 133
If the creditor and principal debtor change the terms of the contract without the consent of the surety, the surety is discharged.
This protects the surety from unexpected risks created by contract changes.
Release of the Principal Debtor — Section 134
If the creditor releases the principal debtor from liability, the surety is also discharged.
This is because the surety’s liability depends on the existence of the principal debtor’s obligation.
Compounding With the Principal Debtor — Section 135
If the creditor:
-
makes a settlement with the debtor, or
-
promises not to sue the debtor
the surety is discharged unless the surety agrees to that arrangement.
Giving Time to the Debtor — Section 136
If the creditor gives additional time to the principal debtor without the surety’s consent, the surety is discharged.
Impairment of Security — Section 139
If the creditor loses or damages security held against the debtor, the surety is discharged to the extent of the value of the lost security.
Practical Illustration
Grace obtains a loan from a bank with Mr. Mwamba as guarantor.
Later, the bank secretly agrees to extend the repayment period by one year without informing Mr. Mwamba.
Under Section 133, this variation discharges Mr. Mwamba from liability because the contract was altered without the surety’s consent.
Key Exam Takeaways
For exam purposes, remember the following points:
Indemnity is governed mainly by:
-
Sections 124–125 of the Law of Contract Act (R.E. 2023)
Guarantee is governed mainly by:
-
Sections 126–147 of the Law of Contract Act (R.E. 2023)
Key distinctions:
-
Indemnity → two parties, primary liability
-
Guarantee → three parties, secondary liability
Important rights of a surety:
-
Subrogation (Section 140)
-
Indemnity from principal debtor (Section 145)
-
Contribution among co-sureties (Section 146)
Important discharge situations:
-
Variation of contract without consent
-
Release of principal debtor
-
Creditor giving extra time to debtor
-
Loss of security
Understanding these principles is essential because contracts of guarantee are widely used in banking, lending, and commercial transactions in Tanzania.
Test yourself
Contracts of Indemnity and Guarantee Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback
