Law explained

Objection Proceedings in Tanzania: Order XXI Rules 57 to 62

Objection proceedings in Tanzania under Order XXI rules 57 to 62 CPC: who can object, procedure, burden of proof, and why the remedy is a suit, not an appeal.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 5 min read
Objection Proceedings in Tanzania: Order XXI Rules 57 to 62

In short

Objection proceedings let a person who is not the judgment debtor ask the executing court to release property attached in execution of a decree, usually because it belongs to them. Under Order XXI rules 57 to 62 of the Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2023, the objector must prove an interest in or possession of the property at the date of attachment. The order is not appealable; the losing party may file a suit under rule 62.

On this page 6 sections
  1. What are objection proceedings?
  2. Which law governs objection proceedings in Tanzania?
  3. Who can file objection proceedings?
  4. How do you file objection proceedings?
  5. Can you appeal against an order in objection proceedings?
  6. What is the difference between objection proceedings and a rule 62 suit?

Objection proceedings let a person who is not the judgment debtor stop the attachment of property that is theirs. When a decree holder attaches a car, a house or a bank account to satisfy a decree, the true owner, or anyone with an interest in it, can apply to the executing court to investigate and release the property. The procedure is in Order XXI rules 57 to 62 of the Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2023.

This guide covers who can object, the law, the step-by-step procedure, what the objector must prove, and what to do if you lose, since the order cannot be appealed. It supports Execution of Decrees in our Civil Procedure notes.

What are objection proceedings?

They are proceedings inside an execution in which a claimant or objector says that attached property is not liable to attachment, usually because it does not belong to the judgment debtor. The executing court investigates the claim with the same powers it would have if the objector were a party to the suit.

Example. Rehema obtains a decree against Baraka. The court broker attaches a pickup at Baraka’s yard. The pickup in fact belongs to Baraka’s brother, Musa, who had lent it to him. Musa files objection proceedings with the registration card and a sale agreement in his name. If the court is satisfied, it releases the pickup from attachment.

Not for mortgages: a bank selling mortgaged property under its own power of sale is not executing a decree, so Order XXI objection proceedings do not apply. They only arise where property is attached in execution of a court decree.

Which law governs objection proceedings in Tanzania?

Order XXI rules 57 to 62 of the Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2023.

Rule What it does
57(1) The court must investigate any claim or objection that attached property is not liable to attachment, treating the objector as if a party to the suit. No investigation where the court considers the objection was designedly or unnecessarily delayed.
57(2) If the property has been advertised for sale, the court may postpone the sale pending the investigation.
58 The objector must produce evidence that, at the date of attachment, they had some interest in, or possession of, the property.
59 The court releases the property, wholly or partly, if it was not in the judgment debtor’s possession on his own account when attached, or was held in trust for someone else.
60 The court disallows the claim if the property was in the judgment debtor’s possession as his own, or held in trust for him, or occupied by a tenant paying rent to him.
61 If the property is subject to a mortgage or charge in favour of someone not in possession, the attachment may continue subject to that charge.
62 The losing party may file a suit to establish the right claimed. Subject to that suit, the order is conclusive.

District Land and Housing Tribunals apply the same rules in executing their decrees, through section 51 of the Land Disputes Courts Act, Cap. 216 R.E. 2023.

Who can file objection proceedings?

  • The owner of attached property who is not the judgment debtor.
  • A person with an interest in it, such as a co-owner, a buyer who paid before attachment, or a person holding it under a lease.
  • A person in possession on their own account at the date of attachment.
  • A bank or other holder who claims a prior right to money attached under a garnishee order. See Amana Bank Ltd v Mantrac Tanzania Ltd & Others [2022] TZHCComD 335, where the bank failed because it could not show an interest existing when the order nisi was issued.

The judgment debtor cannot use objection proceedings to protect their own property. Their remedies are a stay of execution or showing cause in the execution itself.

How do you file objection proceedings?

  1. Act immediately. File as soon as you learn of the attachment. Under the proviso to rule 57(1), the court will refuse to investigate an objection that was designedly or unnecessarily delayed, especially after the sale.
  2. File in the executing court, the court or tribunal that ordered the attachment, in the same execution file.
  3. Prepare a chamber summons under Order XXI rule 57(1) and (2) and section 95 of the Civil Procedure Code, asking the court to investigate the claim, release the property and postpone any sale.
  4. Swear an affidavit showing your interest or possession at the date of attachment, attaching evidence: title deed, registration card, sale agreement, receipts, lease or bank records.
  5. Serve the decree holder and judgment debtor. The decree holder usually files a counter affidavit.
  6. Hearing and investigation. The court hears the parties orally or by written submissions and may take evidence. The objector must prove the claim on the balance of probabilities.
  7. Order. The court releases the property under rule 59, disallows the claim under rule 60, or continues the attachment subject to a charge under rule 61.

Our objection proceedings application template has a full sample chamber summons, affidavit and counter affidavit.

Can you appeal against an order in objection proceedings?

No. The order is conclusive, subject only to a separate suit under rule 62.

Thomas Joseph Kimaro v Apaisaria Martin Carl Mkumbo & Another [2002] TLR 369 (CAT). Decisions in objection proceedings are final and not appealable. The aggrieved party’s remedy is to file a suit to establish their right to the property.

Bank of Tanzania v Devram P. Valambhia, Civil Reference No. 4 of 2002 [2003] TZCA 38. Because Tanzania kept rule 62 in its original form, there is no right of appeal; a suit must be filed instead, and the decision in that suit can be appealed.

The Court of Appeal restated this in Sosthenes Bruno & Another v Flora Shauri, Civil Appeal No. 249 of 2020, and in National Housing Corporation v Peter Kassidi & Others, Civil Application No. 294/16 of 2017. Revision is generally not the proper route either, because rule 62 provides the remedy of a suit.

What is the difference between objection proceedings and a rule 62 suit?

Point Objection proceedings Suit under rule 62
Where Executing court, within the execution Any court with jurisdiction, as a fresh suit
Question decided Mainly possession or interest at the date of attachment The full right or title to the property
Speed Summary and quick Full trial
Appeal None Normal appeal lies

Key Statutes and Cases

Statutes

  • Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2023, Order XXI rules 57 to 62 and section 95
  • Land Disputes Courts Act, Cap. 216 R.E. 2023, section 51

Cases

  • Thomas Joseph Kimaro v Apaisaria Martin Carl Mkumbo & Another [2002] TLR 369
  • Bank of Tanzania v Devram P. Valambhia [2003] TZCA 38
  • Sosthenes Bruno & Another v Flora Shauri, Civil Appeal No. 249 of 2020 (CAT)
  • National Housing Corporation v Peter Kassidi & Others, Civil Application No. 294/16 of 2017 (CAT)
  • Amana Bank Ltd v Mantrac Tanzania Ltd & Others [2022] TZHCComD 335

Key Takeaways

  • Objection proceedings protect third parties whose property is wrongly attached.
  • The law is Order XXI rules 57 to 62 of the Civil Procedure Code.
  • File quickly: a designedly or unnecessarily delayed objection will not be investigated.
  • The objector must prove interest or possession at the date of attachment (rule 58).
  • The court releases the property (rule 59) or disallows the claim (rule 60).
  • Orders are conclusive and not appealable; the remedy is a suit under rule 62.
  • Bank sales under a mortgage are not execution, so these rules do not apply to them.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who can file objection proceedings?

Anyone other than the judgment debtor who had an interest in, or possession of, the attached property at the date of attachment, such as the owner, a co-owner or a buyer.

What must the objector prove?

Under Order XXI rule 58, evidence that at the date of attachment they had some interest in or possession of the property. The standard is the balance of probabilities.

Is there a time limit for objection proceedings?

No fixed number of days, but under the proviso to rule 57(1) the court will not investigate an objection that was designedly or unnecessarily delayed.

Can I appeal against an order in objection proceedings?

No. Under Order XXI rule 62 the order is conclusive. The remedy is to file a suit to establish your right to the property, as held in Thomas Joseph Kimaro v Apaisaria Mkumbo.

Which court hears objection proceedings?

The executing court, meaning the court or tribunal that ordered the attachment.

Do objection proceedings stop the sale?

The court may postpone a sale of advertised property while it investigates the claim, under rule 57(2).

Can a judgment debtor file objection proceedings?

No. The judgment debtor should seek a stay of execution or show cause in the execution itself.

Study This Further

Study Every LLB Subject in One Place

Clear notes on Tanzanian law, practice quizzes and court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Soma topic kamiliExecution of DecreesRead topic